Yogi Berra Baseball Cards: Values and Collector’s Guide

Yogi Berra baseball cards collection featuring rookie and career highlights

Items of Yankee legends are always popular among sports collectors and Yogi Berra baseball cards are no exception.

One of the most well-known names in baseball history, he also became a cultural icon for his funny sayings like “the future ain’t what it used to be” and “I never said most of the things I said”.

Born Lawrence Berra, he earned the nickname “Yogi” from a childhood friend who thought he looked similar to an Indian yogi he saw during a movie.

Yogi went on to be one of the best (if not the best) catchers and most feared hitters of all-time.

A 3-time MVP, 15-time All-Star and member of 10 World Series championship teams, Berra’s place in baseball history is forever cemented.

Here is a list of the 22 best Yogi Berra cards that any serious collector should pursue.

Let’s jump right in!

Player Snapshot Yogi Berra HOF 1972

Player Bio

Position

Catcher

Teams

New York Yankees, New York Mets

Career

1946–1965 (19 yrs)

Career Highlights

•18× All-Star

•10× World Series champion (player, MLB record)

•3× AL MVP (1951, 1954, 1955)

•358 career home runs as catcher

•1972 Hall of Fame inductee

•New York Yankees No. 8 retired

•MLB All-Century Team


Card Universe

Most Valuable Card

1955 Topps #198 Yogi Berra

$4,450 in PSA 8

Most Graded

1956 Topps #110 Yogi Berra

4,667 graded by PSA

Most Affordable

1955 Bowman #168 Yogi Berra

$225 in PSA 5

Ross Uitts

Selling cards like these? Tell me what you’ve got and I’ll tell you what I’d pay.

  • 1947 Tip Top Bread Yogi Berra

    Value
    Total PSA Population
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    The 1948 Bowman #6 is the only official Yogi Berra rookie card in the hobby.

    The small 2 1/16″ by 2 1/2″ black and white card shows a very young Berra looking up after a swing.

    Mint condition cards are almost impossible to come by, and will easily run for thousands of dollars.

    By 1948, Berra had been playing with the Yankees for two seasons.

    Over the next 14 years, a season would not pass that Yogi was not called up to play for at least 100 games.

    Along with the Warren Spahn and Stan Musial rookie cards, this one is the key to the set.

    1947 Tip Top Bread  Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1948 Bowman #6 Yogi Berra Rookie Card

    Rookie Card
    Value
    Total PSA Population 2,476
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    210
    263
    267
    369
    297
    263
    147
    109
    11
    1
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    The 1948 Bowman #6 is the only official Yogi Berra rookie card in the hobby.

    The small 2 1/16″ by 2 1/2″ black and white card shows a very young Berra looking up after a swing.

    Mint condition cards are almost impossible to come by, and will easily run for thousands of dollars.

    By 1948, Berra had been playing with the Yankees for two seasons.

    Over the next 14 years, a season would not pass that Yogi was not called up to play for at least 100 games.

    Along with the Warren Spahn and Stan Musial rookie cards, this one is the key to the set.

    1948 Bowman #6 Yogi Berra Rookie Card
  • 1949 Bowman #60 Yogi Berra

    PSA 3 Value $575 – $600
    Total PSA Population 1,188
    PSA 3 Population 120
    PSA 3 Grade Rate 10.1% (Set Avg: 6.3%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    67
    105
    120
    164
    161
    155
    116
    79
    16
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    1949 would be the first of five times in a row that the Yankees would win the World Series with Yogi on the field.

    His ability to hit low pitches into home runs made him a huge asset to the team’s success.

    He was once again called up to the All-Star team for the second year in his young career.

    The bright red background, while the rest of the colors remain muted, give the picture a surreal look.

    His name does not appear anywhere on the front of the card as he was part of the first half of the 1949 Bowman print run which didn’t include player nameplates.

    1949 Bowman #60 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1950 Bowman #46 Yogi Berra

    PSA 5 Value $650
    Total PSA Population 1,157
    PSA 5 Population 147
    PSA 5 Grade Rate 12.7% (Set Avg: 14.0%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    87
    138
    148
    196
    147
    107
    85
    56
    4
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    Before Topps arrived on the scene and took over the world of baseball cards, Bowman was the go to for kids collecting cards.

    The 1950 set was especially amazing because for the first time ever it featured full color, hand painted renditions of real photos of the players.

    Any collector would want to have a piece of what many have called one of the most important sets in baseball card history.

    Yogi is shown squatting and arm cocked, ready to gun out a would-be base runner.

    1950 Bowman #46 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1951 Berk Ross #2-4 Yogi Berra

    PSA 5 Value $550
    Total PSA Population
    PSA 5 Population
    PSA 5 Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    1951 Berk Ross #2-4 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1951 Bowman #2 Yogi Berra

    PSA 5 Value $700 – $725
    Total PSA Population 1,671
    PSA 5 Population 217
    PSA 5 Grade Rate 13.0% (Set Avg: 13.3%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    161
    188
    241
    260
    217
    153
    103
    61
    8
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    As the Yankees went on to win the World Series for a third consecutive time, Yogi would be awarded his first title of American League Most Valuable Player.

    The card commemorating this great year shows a close up of Berra smiling in his pinstripe jersey.

    Also of note is the use of his real name “Larry” along the bottom of the card.

    It’s a beautiful card but centering and other condition challenges are still an issue.

    1951 Bowman #2 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1951 Topps Major League All-Stars Yogi Berra

    Value
    Total PSA Population
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    1951 Topps Major League All-Stars  Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1952 Berk Ross Yogi Berra

    Value
    Total PSA Population
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    1952 Berk Ross  Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1952 Bowman #1 Yogi Berra

    Value
    Total PSA Population 1,723
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    198
    263
    244
    268
    174
    125
    111
    56
    6
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    Yogi followed up his amazing ‘51 season with 98 RBI in and 30 home runs, which would be his all-time career high.

    He was once again an All-Star and World Series champ.

    This card often suffers from toning problems, staining and centering issues but it’s still a very attractive issue.

    The artist’s rendition features a focused Berra, ready at the plate, along with his autograph across the image.

    It would be one of two mainstream cards on which Berra appeared that year.

    1952 Bowman #1 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1952 Red Man Tobacco #3 Yogi Berra

    Value
    Total PSA Population
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    1952 Red Man Tobacco #3 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1952 Topps #191 Yogi Berra

    PSA 5 Value $1,900 – $1,950
    Total PSA Population 2,326
    PSA 5 Population 306
    PSA 5 Grade Rate 13.2% (Set Avg: 17.6%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    212
    340
    335
    377
    306
    180
    84
    28
    3
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    This card is the most valuable of Yogi’s career even though it was issued several years after his rookie season–something you don’t see too often in the hobby.

    The iconic ’52 Topps set features full color photos of candid shots of each player.

    Yogi’s name and autograph are surrounded by stars with a Yankees logo nearby.

    The set is one of the most difficult to collect as there are varying numbers depending on if you’re trying to collect the basic set or the true master set.

    Pair that with the outrageously high prices of many of the cards, and you’ve got yourself one of the hardest sets to own.

    The Mantle and Mays cards easily outshine every other player in the set but Berra’s is still key.

    Tilting and centering are typical challenges with this card.

    1952 Topps #191 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1953 Bowman Color #121 Yogi Berra

    Value
    Total PSA Population 1,168
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    57
    119
    153
    197
    168
    128
    66
    60
    9
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    Bowman stepped up their game in 1953 by offering full-color, large-sized cards featuring the 160 best major league players.

    Nothing else appears on the front of these cards, with all focus on the picture of the player.

    Yogi’s card in this set is one of the entire collection’s most important cards.

    It is incredibly difficult to find in good condition, as many specimens feature print lines and poor centering.

    Relaxing in the dugout, it’s easy to envision Yogi laying out one of his famous sayings in this picture.

    1953 Bowman Color #121 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1953 Topps #104 Yogi Berra

    PSA 5 Value $625 – $650
    Total PSA Population 3,137
    PSA 5 Population 461
    PSA 5 Grade Rate 14.7% (Set Avg: 17.3%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    221
    357
    393
    546
    461
    303
    156
    82
    8
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    It would be the last of the five year streak of World Series wins for the Yankees.

    Yogi would be called up to the All-Star game once again for his stellar performance during the season.

    The card features a portrait of Berra with his cap on and a determined look on his face.

    His name, position and team are found in a red box at the bottom left corner.

    A beautiful card, no doubt, it’s still one of the few of his mainstream issues where he’s not smiling.

    Chipping along the red bottom border is a common concern for collectors.

    1953 Topps #104 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1954 Bowman #161 Yogi Berra

    Value
    Total PSA Population 1,932
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    57
    137
    211
    302
    275
    275
    198
    129
    19
    2
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    In 1954, Yogi received his second of three American League Most Valuable Player titles.

    The card has an excellent full color photo of Yogi smiling on it.

    Underneath in a salmon colored box, Yogi’s signature appears.

    For such a great looking card, the price tag isn’t as steep as many Berra cards.

    The backs of the cards in this set are graced with trivia questions, humorous anecdotes and player records.

    1954 Bowman #161 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1954 Topps #50 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $2,400 – $2,500
    Total PSA Population 3,688
    PSA 8 Population 127
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 3.4% (Set Avg: 11.3%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    147
    352
    487
    645
    539
    475
    282
    127
    14
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    Topps embraced a whole new design for their ‘54 set.

    Yogi’s card has a bold green background with a black and white cut-out action shot of him swinging the bat.

    A larger, cut-out color photo of Yogi about to make a catch steals the focus of the card.

    His signature trails across the bottom of the card while his name, team and position are recorded at the top.

    These cards are prone to rounded corners and centering issues, which devalues them drastically.

    1954 Topps #50 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
    Ross Uitts

    Got a shoebox of cards like these? Even if none of them are the stars on this list, I’d like to see them — most of the collections I buy are commons and mid-grade stars.

    Get An Offer →Or text a photo: 305-684-6680

  • 1955 Bowman #168 Yogi Berra

    PSA 5 Value $220 – $230
    Total PSA Population 1,926
    PSA 5 Population 265
    PSA 5 Grade Rate 13.8% (Set Avg: 12.5%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    77
    160
    234
    309
    265
    256
    160
    72
    5
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    Bowman clearly put some creative thought into their 1955 set.

    Photos of players are in borders that are meant to look like color TVs.

    Berra has his bat over his shoulder, ready to hit whatever comes to him.

    The only problem with the awesome TV borders is that the dark brown color chips so easily.

    Only his last name “Berra” accompanies him on this card.

    1955 Bowman #168 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1955 Topps #198 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $4,400 – $4,500
    Total PSA Population 2,930
    PSA 8 Population 96
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 3.3% (Set Avg: 10.2%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    90
    212
    294
    510
    464
    400
    227
    96
    12
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    The Yankees faced the Brooklyn Dodgers in the 1955 World Series, a series in which one of the most iconic moments in the game’s history took place.

    Down 4-6 in the top of the 8th of Game 1, Jackie Robinson famously stole home plate–something Berra remained upset about for years thereafter.

    The match-up would end up being a 7 game battle, one which the Yankees would inevitably lose.

    In game 7 of the championship, Yogi hit a fly ball in the sixth inning that had the potential to change the game, but Dodgers’ left fielder Sandy Amorós caught it, which sealed the Yankees’ fate.

    The horizontal design, a first for Topps, and the bright yellow borders make this card one of the more attractive Yogi Berra baseball cards.

    Centering and print blotches in the yellow background are common problems.

    1955 Topps #198 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1956 Topps #110 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $1,650 – $1,700
    Total PSA Population 4,667
    PSA 8 Population 285
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 6.1% (Set Avg: 16.0%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    194
    314
    517
    755
    721
    735
    458
    285
    36
    2
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    The Yankees would have their chance at redemption in 1956, as once again they would end up facing the Dodgers in the World Series.

    This time, the Yankees brought the heat.

    Even though Berra helped catch in Don Larsen’s perfect, no hit game, the teams still pushed the battle to a game 7.

    Much to the credit of Yogi, who hit a homerun and batted 4 runners in, the Yankees smashed the Dodgers in a 9-0 domination.

    The whole season was a great one for Berra, giving him many of his personal bests which still hold to this day.

    Another great horizontal issue, Berra is is depicted in a close up head shot along the left and in a small action shot on the right.

    1956 Topps #110 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1957 Topps #2 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $1,050 – $1,100
    Total PSA Population 4,015
    PSA 8 Population 245
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 6.1% (Set Avg: 19.4%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    83
    236
    391
    674
    641
    727
    502
    245
    18
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    The 1957 Topps set was fairly large in size, at 407 cards.

    While Yogi’s teammate, Mickey Mantle, is the real star of the set, Berra’s card still sells close to $3,000 in top condition.

    The focus in ‘57 was elsewhere in New York, as it would be the last season for the Brooklyn Dodgers and the New York Giants before the teams relocated to the west coaSt. His ’57 Topps issue is a sharp-looking card with a full on headshot of the Yankee legend on center stage.

    Centering is probably the number one condition issue that affects this card.

    1957 Topps #2 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1958 Topps #370 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $950 – $975
    Total PSA Population 2,971
    PSA 8 Population 218
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 7.3% (Set Avg: 16.7%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    78
    184
    284
    516
    453
    479
    339
    218
    25
    1
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    Topps decided to punch up the color factor in the 1958 set.

    Each card has one of nine different brightly colored backgrounds.

    The backs of these cards featured small cartoons about the players.

    Yogi’s card is electric orange with a cutout photo of him smiling over top.

    A blue banner at the bottom reads his position and team name.

    It was an excellent season for Yogi.

    He played 88 perfect games landing him one of several 1.000 fielding averages in his career.

    Centering and print blotches are typically the biggest challenges for this card.

    1958 Topps #370 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1959 Topps #180 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $775 – $800
    Total PSA Population 3,653
    PSA 8 Population 240
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 6.6% (Set Avg: 23.5%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    91
    235
    393
    633
    566
    584
    476
    240
    24
    1
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    Berra was the first catcher to keep one finger out of the glove while catching.

    Many other catchers followed suit in the years to come.

    Yogi would once again make it to the All-Star team in 1959.

    The Topps set from that year was bold and totally new in design.

    A circular photo of Berra holding the bat with his autograph across it lays in front of an orange background.

    His name trails diagonally upwards at the the top of the card.

    1959 Topps #180 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1959 Yoo Hoo Yogi Berra

    Value
    Total PSA Population
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    1959 Yoo Hoo  Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1960 Bazooka #8 Yogi Berra

    Value
    Total PSA Population
    Population 0
    Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    1960 Bazooka #8 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1960 Topps #480 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $700 – $725
    Total PSA Population 3,791
    PSA 8 Population 209
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 5.5% (Set Avg: 21.9%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    82
    198
    324
    610
    635
    826
    556
    209
    16
    1
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    The Yankees would find themselves once again in a World Series, this time facing the Pittsburgh Pirates.

    In what would be a devastating Game 7 loss, the Pirates’ Bill Mazeroski would hit a homerun that would win the game 10-9.

    The Yankees both outhit and outscored the Pirates, but one bad pitch would doom the game.

    It’s the last time Berra was featured on a horizontally-designed mainstream card.

    The iconic 1960 Topps card design displays a small black and white action shot of Berra on the left and a larger head shot on the right.

    Print dots can affect these cards but they’re still great looking.

    1960 Topps #480 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
    Ross Uitts

    Two or three of these and a few hundred commons? That’s what most collections I buy look like. You’ll have a real number within 48 hours, and you ship nothing until you like it.

    Get An Offer →Or text a photo: 305-684-6680

  • 1961 Post Cereal #1 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $525
    Total PSA Population
    PSA 8 Population
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)

    1961 Post Cereal #1 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1961 Topps #425 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $700 – $725
    Total PSA Population 3,162
    PSA 8 Population 310
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 9.8% (Set Avg: 27.9%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    38
    90
    255
    417
    462
    607
    577
    310
    30
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    The 1961 Topps set is considered a classic despite its somewhat plain appearance.

    Print bubbles can appear in the colored blocks at the bottom but for the most part this is one of the easier sets in the ’60s to find in high grade.

    Yogi’s card features a posed photo of him smiling, bat in hand.

    The backs of the card had no humorous anecdotes, just the plain old stats about each player.

    The Yankees would win yet another World Series in ‘61, this time against the Cincinnati Reds.

    This was their 19th championship win out of 39 seasons.

    They won the match-up in just five games, completely crushing the Reds.

    1961 Topps #425 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1962 Topps #360 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $775 – $800
    Total PSA Population 2,471
    PSA 8 Population 157
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 6.4% (Set Avg: 20.7%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    24
    96
    184
    391
    377
    496
    407
    157
    15
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    Once again the Yankees found themselves in a World Series Championship going head to head with Willie Mays and the San Francisco Giants.

    The match went right to game 7, with the Yankees stealing the victory by just one run.

    Yogi was 37 years old by this point, but he still played with stamina, even catching the entirety of a 22 inning game against the Detroit Tigers, which lasted seven whole hours.

    The famous wood-grain borders of the 1962 Topps set present chipping and wear challenges.

    Centering is also a common problem.

    1962 Topps #360 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1963 Topps #340 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $2,400 – $2,500
    Total PSA Population 1,569
    PSA 8 Population 98
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 6.2% (Set Avg: 28.6%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    20
    53
    132
    256
    249
    328
    234
    98
    5
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    This card features two photos of Berra, one small black and white shot of him holding the bat in a bright yellow circle, and a much larger full color photo of him smiling.

    The larger photo really shows his age.

    This would be the year that Yogi would retire as a player for The Yankees, and take his turn as a manager and coach for the team.

    Centering is a severe challenge and the red bottom borders also easily show wear and chipping.

    1963 Topps #340 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1964 Topps #21 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $320 – $330
    Total PSA Population 2,309
    PSA 8 Population 278
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 12.0% (Set Avg: 29.0%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    27
    83
    171
    344
    301
    460
    424
    278
    18
    3
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    Yogi was able to lead the Yankees to the American League pennant against the St Louis Cardinals as a first year coach.

    The Yankees lost the matchup over seven games.

    Berra was having difficulty convincing the team that he was ready to manage, and he eventually was fired from the Yankees, leading to over a decade of bad blood between Yogi and the team.

    One of the easier sets to find in terms of print quality, 1964 Topps Berra cards are much easier to find in top condition.

    It’s also one of two Yogi Berra baseball cards to show him as a manager.

    1964 Topps #21 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
  • 1965 Topps #470 Yogi Berra

    PSA 8 Value $270 – $280
    Total PSA Population 1,917
    PSA 8 Population 444
    PSA 8 Grade Rate 23.2% (Set Avg: 32.9%)

    PSA Population Distribution

    12
    46
    70
    184
    206
    314
    377
    444
    86
    3
    1
    2
    3
    4
    5
    6
    7
    8
    9
    10

    In 1965, Berra officially ended his Yankees career by signing with the New York Mets as a coach.

    He would appear occasionally as a catcher throughout that season, mostly just for show.

    He would continue to be a coach in the years that followed, eventually leading the team to a World Series title.

    Tilt and centering are usually the more common issues with this card.

    1965 Topps #470 Yogi Berra Baseball Card
Ross Uitts Old Sports Cards

Ross’s Take

Ross Uitts

Want an offer on your cards?

Send photos or a description and you’ll have a real number within 48 hours. Shipping is insured and on me, or I’ll come to you. You’re paid the day the cards arrive, and if you say no, they go back to you at my cost.

  • Buying and selling for over 35 years
  • Written for Beckett, Topps, SABR, and more
  • PSA Set Registry member