25 Most Valuable 1989 Score Baseball Cards
If you ask most collectors, 1989 Score baseball cards typically go down as just another nearly-forgotten set of the “junk era.” Their monetary value, like most cards of the late 1980s, has undoubtedly declined because of how widely-printed and distributed they were.
Let’s face it, these cards were everywhere.
But, there are still many great memories packed within its checklist… An instantly recognizable design, multiple Hall of Fame rookie cards, and many superstars of the day can still put a smile on your face if you collected these as a kid.
And in this guide, we’ll take a look at the 25 most valuable.
Let’s jump right in!
1989 Score Baseball Set Snapshot
Stay On Top Of The Card Market
Weekly pricing updates, grading insights, and new card guides — straight to your inbox. For free.
Join thousands of collectors. Unsubscribe anytime.
Ross Uitts – Owner
- #1
1989 Score #300 Nolan Ryan
PSA 10 Value $50Total PSA Population 697PSA 10 Population 382PSA 10 Grade Rate 54.8% (Set Avg: 51.2%)After a successful stint with the Houston Astros, the “Ryan Express” would make his Texas Rangers debut during the 1989 season.
Ryan wasted no time getting started with the Rangers as he pitched well enough to earn his 8th All-Star appearance and eventually led the league in strikeouts (not surprisingly) with 301 that year.
Few pitchers ever crack the 300 strikeout mark in a season but this was the 6th time Ryan had done so and 1st since the 1977 season.
Ryan was 30 years old during the 1977 season, so you can understand him striking out 300+ hitters back then.
But, at age 42, he struck out 301 hitters?
Are you kidding me?
It’s just one of the many things about Ryan’s career that will raise your eyebrows.
- #2
1989 Score #330 Bo Jackson
PSA 10 Value $45Total PSA Population 359PSA 10 Population 179PSA 10 Grade Rate 49.9% (Set Avg: 51.2%)Bo Jackson was everywhere back in the late 1980s: Nike commercials, Nintendo games, you name it.
And because he was one of the biggest superstars of his day, his cards still have a respectable following in the hobby from those who grew up idolizing him as kids.
This card easily ranks among the best in the set when it comes to action shots.
You can almost feel the power generated by his compact and quick swing.
Had injuries not gotten in the way, who knows how great Bo Jackson could have been?
- #3
1989 Score #630 Sandy Alomar Jr. Rookie Card
Rookie CardPSA 10 Value $45Total PSA PopulationPSA 10 PopulationPSA 10 Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 51.2%)Had it not been for Benito Santiago, Sandy Alomar Jr. probably would have been a San Diego Padre for far longer than the eight games in which he played with them during brief appearances in 1988 and 1989.
However, the Padres traded Alomar and teammates Carlos Baerga and Chris James to the Cleveland Indians for Joe Carter during the 1989 off-season.
Alomar’s rookie debut in 1990 was one of the greatest rookie seasons any catcher ever had as he was named Rookie of the Year, won a Gold Glove, and became the first rookie catcher ever to start the All-Star game.
A six-time All-Star, Alomar Jr. was one of the best catchers of his era but never did quite turn in Hall of Fame numbers.
- #4
1989 Score #645 Randy Johnson Rookie Card
Rookie CardPSA 10 Value $45Total PSA Population 6,135PSA 10 Population 2,434PSA 10 Grade Rate 39.7% (Set Avg: 51.2%)What you see on this card is one of the most terrifying images that many MLB hitters saw in their careers: the 6’10” frame of Randy Johnson about to unleash what looks to be his 90+ mph slider that he affectionately dubbed “Mr. Snappy.” Whether it was his slider or his 100 mph fastball, there was a good chance you weren’t going to hit it.
Johnson struggled a bit early on with the Expos and the team quickly gave up on him, trading him to the Mariners on May 25, 1989.
However, he soon transformed into one of the most dominant pitchers the game has ever seen and went on to win 303 games while striking out 4,875 hitters along the way.
Oh, and he won five Cy Young Awards and finished second in Cy Young voting three times.
He was a real joy to watch whenever he stepped on the mound and even though his rookie cards appeared during the “junk era,” I still think they’re undervalued.
- #5
1989 Score #100 Don Mattingly
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA Population 200PSA 10 Population 108PSA 10 Grade Rate 54.0% (Set Avg: 51.2%)Don Mattingly fine-tuned his swing to his own specifications, throwing timing conventions out the window.
“Mattingly’s swing is mechanically unique,” former manager Lou Piniella once said.
“When you have a small takeaway and when you’re as quick as he is, you can look away and handle the ball in.” Mattingly wasn’t just quick to balls inside.
Because he didn’t load his swing back as long as most hitters, the New York Yankees first baseman had more time to gauge pitch speed and placement.
Before the injuries took hold and changed everything, Donnie Baseball was one of the purest, calculated, and deadliest hitters in the Majors.
1989 was the tail end of Mattingly’s reign over the game.
Named to his sixth consecutive All-Star team while earning his fifth Gold Glove, the former MVP slashed .303/.351/.477 with 23 home runs and 113 RBIs in 158 games.
His 191 hits placed seventh in the American League.
- #6
1989 Score #3 Mark McGwire
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA Population 188PSA 10 Population 82PSA 10 Grade Rate 43.6% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #7
1989 Score #15 Cal Ripken Jr.
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA Population 238PSA 10 Population 138PSA 10 Grade Rate 58.0% (Set Avg: 51.2%)Next on the list is none other than the legendary Cal Ripken Jr., arguably the greatest shortstop who ever lived.
A 2-time MVP and 19-time All-Sar, Ripken haunted opposing defenses quite literally day in and day out as he’d eventually go on to set the record for most consecutive games played at 2,632.
Ripken was one of my favorite players growing up and I remember the joy of pulling his cards from packs, this one included.
- #8
1989 Score #35 Ryne Sandberg
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA Population 104PSA 10 Population 72PSA 10 Grade Rate 69.2% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #9
1989 Score #70 Rickey Henderson
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA Population 153PSA 10 Population 84PSA 10 Grade Rate 54.9% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #10
1989 Score #75 George Brett
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA PopulationPSA 10 PopulationPSA 10 Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #11
1989 Score #119 Greg Maddux
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA Population 109PSA 10 Population 39PSA 10 Grade Rate 35.8% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #12
1989 Score #127 Barry Bonds
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA Population 275PSA 10 Population 123PSA 10 Grade Rate 44.7% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #13
1989 Score #149 Mike Schmidt
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA Population 158PSA 10 Population 119PSA 10 Grade Rate 75.3% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #14
1989 Score #151 Robin Yount
PSA 10 Value $30Total PSA Population 84PSA 10 Population 53PSA 10 Grade Rate 63.1% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #15
1989 Score #616 John Smoltz Rookie Card
Rookie CardPSA 10 Value $28Total PSA Population 920PSA 10 Population 538PSA 10 Grade Rate 58.5% (Set Avg: 51.2%)When debating the best starting rotations in MLB history, it’s not a question of whether the Atlanta Braves anchored by Greg Maddux, Tom Glavine and John Smoltz are included, but rather which rotation?
Was it their 1993 staff?
Or how about those rotations from 1996 to 1998?
No matter the year, Smoltz was consistently part of that three-headed monster that terrified opposing hitters throughout the decade.
And he was incredibly versatile, too, as he dominated as a starter through the early part of his career, became a dominant reliever for a few years, and then went back to being a starter again.
Smoltz’s success on the mound made him a natural choice as a first-ballot Hall of Famer in 2015.
His rookie card is one of the keys to this set and will set you back about $20 in PSA 10 grade.
- #16
1989 Score #1 Jose Canseco
PSA 10 Value $25Total PSA Population 100PSA 10 Population 53PSA 10 Grade Rate 53.0% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #17
1989 Score #20 Kirby Puckett
PSA 10 Value $25Total PSA Population 156PSA 10 Population 128PSA 10 Grade Rate 82.1% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #18
1989 Score #30 Dale Murphy
PSA 10 Value $25Total PSA Population 129PSA 10 Population 96PSA 10 Grade Rate 74.4% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #19
1989 Score #80 Ozzie Smith
PSA 10 Value $25Total PSA Population 110PSA 10 Population 77PSA 10 Grade Rate 70.0% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #20
1989 Score #90 Tony Gwynn
PSA 10 Value $25Total PSA Population 201PSA 10 Population 137PSA 10 Grade Rate 68.2% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #21
1989 Score #175 Wade Boggs
PSA 10 Value $25Total PSA Population 69PSA 10 Population 49PSA 10 Grade Rate 71.0% (Set Avg: 51.2%) - #22
1989 Score #237 Craig Biggio Rookie Card
Rookie CardPSA 10 Value $25Total PSA Population 1,350PSA 10 Population 924PSA 10 Grade Rate 68.4% (Set Avg: 51.2%)When it came to playing defense, Craig Biggio was as versatile as they come.
A 4-time Gold Glover at second base, Biggio also spent time in the Majors as a catcher and outfielder.
And the guy was just as good on the offensive side as he totaled 3,060 base hits, scored 1,844 runs and stole 414 bases over his Hall of Fame career.
He was simply one of the most well-rounded and brilliant players of his era.
As rookie cards, this one is pretty straightforward due to the headshot pose but you gotta love that old Astros uniform gives this card some much-needed pop.
- #23
1989 Score #637 Edgar Martinez
PSA 10 Value $25Total PSA Population 344PSA 10 Population 130PSA 10 Grade Rate 37.8% (Set Avg: 51.2%)Beginning in 1973, the “Outstanding Designated Hitter Award” was presented annually to the greatest designated hitter in the American League.
However, since 2004, the award has been referred to simply as the “Edgar Martinez Award”.
That should tell you everything you need to know about the legendary Mariners DH.
From 1990 to 1994, Martinez served primarily as the Mariners’ starting third baseman but in 1995 the team made him their full-time DH.
That season, Martinez would finish third in MVP voting as he put up an incredible stat line with a .356 batting average, .479 OBP, 121 R, 29 home runs and 113 RBI.
It was off to the races for Martinez from that point on and now that he’s a Hall of Famer, his rookie cards have seen a well-deserved boost in value.
- #24
1989 Score #625 Gary Sheffield Rookie Card
Rookie CardPSA 10 Value $25Total PSA Population 587PSA 10 Population 194PSA 10 Grade Rate 33.0% (Set Avg: 51.2%)I remember watching Sheffield and being in awe of his incredible bat speed, a key to his success in smacking 509 home runs over his career.
That powerful swing is on full display on his 1989 Score rookie card which gives it a tremendous amount of eye appeal.
Sheffield bounced around from team to team throughout his career, always playing at a high level and was especially critical to that historical World Series-winning 1997 Florida Marlins team Unfortunately, his legacy is tainted by his connection with the PED scandal, but there is no doubt that he was incredibly talented.
Ross’s Take
Overall, this set typically doesn’t rank among the best of the 1980s but I still think there is plenty to love within the 660-card checkliSt. Rookie cards of Craig Biggio, John Smoltz, Randy Johnson and Gary Sheffield alongside base cards of many superstars of the era still made for a decent set.
And for those who like trivia, how about those “Magic Motion” trivia cards that were included in packs?
The set did lack a significant amount of subsets, but collectors could still enjoy two: Rookie Prospects (#621-651) Highlights (#652-660) In general, the hobby doesn’t look back on 1989 Score with much appreciation but for those who grew up collecting them during that era, there is still plenty of nostalgia to be had within this set.
Love old cards? Get weekly updates from a fellow collector.
Pricing updates, grading insights, and new guides on the cards you actually care about — the junk wax era, vintage, and everything in between. One email a week. No fluff.
Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.
Ross Uitts – Owner
