Joe Montana Rookie Cards: Values, Grading and What’s Worth Buying
If you collect football cards then the 1981 Topps Joe Montana rookie card is an absolute must have.
Not only is it one of the most valuable football cards of the 1980’s, it’s one of the most expensive of all-time.
Montana didn’t possess the strongest arm but what he did better than anyone else was manage the game with consistency and accuracy and find ways to win.
Having Jerry Rice on his team sure didn’t hurt either.
His ability to remain calm under pressure and drive his teams to countless fourth quarter victories earned him nicknames such as “Joe Cool” and “The Comeback Kid”.
That reputation earned him a place as one of the most popular players of all times and his cards are some of the most highly collected as a result.
Let’s jump right in!
Need Help Selling Your Sports Cards?
Fill out the form below and I’ll get back to you within 24 hours. No obligation.
Ross Uitts – Owner
-
1981 Topps #216 Joe Montana Rookie Card
PSA 9 Value $3,600Total PSA Population 36,168PSA 9 Population 2,189PSA 9 Grade Rate 6.1% (Set Avg: 7.9%)PSA Population Distribution
942416051,5803,0296,2888,83810,0762,18911412345678910What drives the value here isn’t scarcity, since the 1981 Topps Montana is actually pretty findable, even in high grade.
It’s Montana himself.
As arguably the greatest quarterback to ever play and the face of the dominant 49ers of the 1980s, he’s one of the most popular players in the hobby, and that demand is what makes his rookie so expensive and sought after.
His rookie didn’t actually arrive until his third pro season.
He barely played in 1979, took over as the starter midway through 1980, then broke out in 1981 by starting every game and leading San Francisco to a 13-3 finish.
The back nods to his Notre Dame days and the 1977 national title he won there, which is remarkable when you remember he was once a seventh-string quarterback for the Irish.
Condition is the real hurdle.
The 1981 Topps football set was notorious for centering problems, and you’ll also run into print defects, chipping, and general wear.
It’s the undisputed key to the set, headlining a rookie class that also features Dan Hampton, Art Monk, and his own teammate Dwight Clark.
Other Early Key Career Cards
Beyond his 1981 Topps rookie, Montana has a couple of scarce oddball issues that make for fun deep cuts.
These weren’t mainstream cards sold in packs.
They came from regional promotions and specialty releases, which is exactly why they’re so much harder to find today.
There’s the 1981 MSA Holsum Disc, a round, blank-backed disc tucked into loaves of bread that shows a rare mustached portrait of him, and the oversized Coral-Lee postcard from his early 49ers years.
Neither one is a rookie, and neither carries the weight of the Topps issue, but for the collector who already owns his mainstream rookie and wants something different and unusual, these early oddballs are where the chase gets interesting.
-
1979-83 Coral-Lee Postcards Joe Montana
PSA 9 Value $300Total PSA PopulationPSA 9 PopulationPSA 9 Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)Coral-Lee’s Sports Superstars series was a run of oversized postcards spotlighting the biggest names in sports, and Montana’s entry is a scarce and appealing early oddball.
Catalogued as part of the 1979-83 issue, it captures him in the early stretch of his 49ers career, right around the time he was emerging as a star.
Postcards like these were never sold in packs or distributed the way mainstream cards were, so they tend to be much harder to track down today.
The oversized, postcard format sets it apart from a standard card and gives it a distinctive look in a collection.
It’s not a rookie, and it won’t carry the weight of his Topps issue, but for a Montana collector who wants something different and rare from his early years, this Coral-Lee postcard is a rewarding, offbeat deep cut.
-
1981 MSA Holsum Discs Joe Montana
PSA 9 Value $600Total PSA PopulationPSA 9 PopulationPSA 9 Grade Rate 0.0% (Set Avg: 0.0%)Here’s one of the more unusual pieces from Montana’s rookie year, and a fun oddball for any collector.
The 1981 MSA Holsum Discs weren’t cards in the traditional sense at all.
They were round, blank-backed discs about 2 3/4 inches across, produced by Michael Schechter Associates and tucked one at a time into specially marked loaves of Holsum and Gardner’s bread.
Because they were only handed out through a regional bread promotion, they never saw wide distribution, which keeps the whole 32-disc set on the scarce side today.
Montana’s disc is the key to the set, and it stands out even beyond that.
His portrait is done in black and white apart from the colored border, and it shows him with a mustache, a look you almost never see on his cards.
Since the set was licensed only through the NFL Players Association, there are no team logos anywhere on it.
For a Montana collector who already owns the Topps rookie, this is a rewarding and offbeat deep cut from the same year.
Ross’s Take
Montana went on to become one of the greatest quarterbacks of all time.
He was an 8-time Pro Bowler, 2-time MVP, and 4-time Super Bowl champion.
His dominance of the 1980’s is the stuff of legend.
At a time when the 49ers had struggled for years, he was exactly what they needed when he stepped into the starter role permanently in 1981.
It’s surprising given that the team took him in the third round of the 1979 draft.
What a steal!
You won’t find him ranking in the top 10 of many of the main quarterback stat categories but the game has changed immensely since Montana played.
Nowadays, the game is so pass heavy that it’s not really fair to compare some of his stat totals to players of today.
But people will never forget how cool under pressure he was.
And how he could lead a team from behind for a win.
There’s likely no one else you’d want at the quarterback position when the game was on the line than Joe Montana.
Elected in his first year of eligibility to the Hall of Fame in 2000, he was the first 3-time Super Bowl MVP.
And he still holds the Super Bowl record of most passes without an interception at 122 and highest quarterback rating of 127.8.
See what I mean?
How could you not want him under center when it counts the most?
That’s what makes Joe Montana football cards so collectible.
