25 Most Valuable 1968 Topps Baseball Cards
Instantly recognizable due to their burlap-colored borders, the 1968 Topps baseball card set is packed with Hall of Famers and anchored by two key rookie cards.
One of those rookie cards actually sold for well into the six figure range during an auction in 2016…
Many collectors feel that the design of this set is one of Topps’ least favorable of the 1960’s but personally, I love them.
True, the burlap borders do easily show wear and tear but I think it’s always nice to mix things up once in a while and Topps easily accomplished that in this case.
Love them or hate them, this set definitely has its place in the vintage card collecting circle.
And in this guide, I’ll run through the 25 most valuable to look for.
Let’s jump right in!
1968 Topps Baseball Set Snapshot
SET DETAILS
598
Nolan Ryan, Johnny Bench
Mickey Mantle, Hank Aaron, Roberto Clemente, Willie Mays, Pete Rose
GRADING ANALYSIS
390,487
TOTAL GRADED BY PSA
116,514
PSA 8 Population
29.8%
PSA 8 Grade Rate
MOST GRADED CARDS
1
#177 Mets Rookies Jerry Koosman/Nolan Ryan
4.8%
18,786
2
#280 Mickey Mantle
4.6%
17,826
3
#247 Reds Rookies Johnny Bench/Ron Tompkins
3.7%
14,405
Need Help Selling Your Sports Cards?
Fill out the form below and I’ll get back to you within 24 hours. No obligation.
Ross Uitts – Owner
- #1
1968 Topps #177 Nolan Ryan Rookie Card
Rookie CardPSA 8 Value $8,000Total PSA Population 18,786PSA 8 Population 756PSA 8 Grade Rate 4.0% (Set Avg: 29.8%)The Nolan Ryan rookie card is by far and away the most valuable in the 1968 Topps set.
Collectors often joke that their Jerry Koosman rookie card is the most valuable in the set since Ryan actually shares this card with him.
Koosman may not have had the career Ryan did but he would go on to be named to two All-Star teams and even once finished second in voting for the Cy Young award.
Clearly, Nolan Ryan is the star of this card, which is one of the most valuable and important vintage baseball cards in the hobby.
In fact, a Nolan Ryan rookie graded in PSA 10 Gem Mint condition sold for an incredible $612,360 at auction in 2016.
- #2
1968 Topps #400 Mike McCormick White Team Letters
PSA 8 Value $4,000Total PSA Population 181PSA 8 Population 23PSA 8 Grade Rate 12.7% (Set Avg: 29.8%)This is a prime example of how the value of a baseball card can be heavily impacted because of a simple variation.
The regular version of this card will show the Giants team name in yellow letters.
However, some examples made it off the printing press with the team name in white letters.
Far fewer white letter variations exist so collectors are willing to pay huge premiums for the card to complete an entire master set.
Though he was not a Hall of Famer, McCormick actually won the Cy Young award for his work in the 1967 season.
- #3
1968 Topps #280 Mickey Mantle
PSA 8 Value $2,250Total PSA Population 17,826PSA 8 Population 1,236PSA 8 Grade Rate 6.9% (Set Avg: 29.8%)Mickey Mantle cards will always be at or near the top of any list of most desirable cards in any set in which he appeared.
The Mick was larger than life and fans adored the Yankees slugger.
Of all his regular Topps issues, this is his least valuable.
That just shows you how valuable his cards can be when his “cheapest” card is almost at the top of this liSt. I’ve always loved this card as it gives a great shot of Mantle batting lefty with intense concentration in his legendary Yankee pinstripes.
The 1968 season would be Mantle’s last as a professional baseball player.
- #4
1968 Topps #247 Johnny Bench Rookie Card
Rookie CardPSA 8 Value $1,700Total PSA Population 14,405PSA 8 Population 1,127PSA 8 Grade Rate 7.8% (Set Avg: 29.8%)The other key rookie card in this set would belong to Johnny Bench.
Bench easily goes down in history as one of the game’s all-time greatest catchers but because his popularity didn’t quite reach the heights of Nolan Ryan, his rookie card can be had for much less.
The young Bench stares off into the distance wearing a backwards Reds cap on a bright blue day, giving this card a huge amount of character and eye appeal.
Centering can often be a challenge with this card as you’ll often find it favoring one or more borders.
- #5
1968 Topps #50 Willie Mays
PSA 8 Value $950Total PSA Population 5,794PSA 8 Population 540PSA 8 Grade Rate 9.3% (Set Avg: 29.8%)Willie Mays baseball cards are always among the keys to any set in which he was included since he was arguably one of the top five best baseball players who ever played.
Mays could do it all…
He could hit, field, and run at incredible levels that are rarely seen by themselves, let alone all in one package of a single player.
Mays is shown hoisting a pair of bats over one should and staring off to the left.
I wish Topps would’ve chose a more exciting shot for such a high profile legend, but it’s tough to complain too much about any Mays card…
Mays’ offensive production had started to dip during the season before but he was still playing at a high enough level in 1968 to earn his 15th All-Star appearance…in a row.
- #6
1968 Topps #110 Hank Aaron
PSA 8 Value $800Total PSA Population 6,591PSA 8 Population 755PSA 8 Grade Rate 11.5% (Set Avg: 29.8%)Next up is legendary slugger Hank Aaron.
The 1968 season was kind of a down year for Aaron as he failed to do what he so often did season after season: hit above .300, hit 30+ home runs and drive in 90+ RBI.
Regardless, his performance on the field was still good enough to land him his 14th All-Star appearance in a row.
Aaron was one of the game’s greatest hitters of all-time and he routinely struck fear into the hearts and minds of opposing pitchers.
- #7
1968 Topps #490 Super Stars
PSA 8 Value $750Total PSA Population 5,295PSA 8 Population 609PSA 8 Grade Rate 11.5% (Set Avg: 29.8%)This is a fantastic card depicting three of the game’s all-time greats in Harmon Killebrew, Willie Mays and Mickey Mantle.
Between this trio of bombers, they hit a jaw-dropping 1,769 home runs with Mays topping the list: Willie Mays: 660 Harmon Killebrew: 573 Mickey Mantle: 536 Had Killebrew played on a larger market team, we would likely hear a lot more about him.
Regardless, he was an amazing baseball player.
That goes for all three of these guys and thankfully, Topps created this wonderful card as a nice tribute to them.
- #8
1968 Topps #150 Roberto Clemente
PSA 8 Value $700Total PSA Population 6,155PSA 8 Population 575PSA 8 Grade Rate 9.3% (Set Avg: 29.8%)Along with Mantle, Mays and Aaron, Roberto Clemente cards are some of the most sought after of the 1950’s and 1960’s.
This one is no exception.
Donning his Pittsburgh Pirates gear, Clemente stands at bat staring intently off into the distance.
Not enough good things can be said about Clemente.
Not only was he an amazing ball player, his dedication to humanitarian efforts truly place him in another class.
Major League Baseball did well in creating the Roberto Clemente Award which is given annually to the player who “best exemplifies the game of baseball, sportsmanship, community involvement and the individual’s contribution to his team.”
- #9
1968 Topps #45 Tom Seaver
PSA 8 Value $550Total PSA Population 8,849PSA 8 Population 831PSA 8 Grade Rate 9.4% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #10
1968 Topps #230 Pete Rose
PSA 8 Value $500Total PSA Population 5,733PSA 8 Population 600PSA 8 Grade Rate 10.5% (Set Avg: 29.8%)What a great look at Pete Rose standing in a batting pose doing what he did best: getting ready to hit the baseball.
During the 1968 season, Rose would bat .335 which earned him his first of three batting titles throughout his career.
Rose will always be surrounded by controversy due to his involvement in gambling on baseball but you can’t argue how good of a hitter he was.
His playing ability keeps his popularity extremely high with players and he’s always among the keys to the set.
I love those old cutoff uniforms of that era and Rose’s red undershirt mixed with his Reds uniform give this card strong eye appeal.
- #11
1968 Topps #80 Rod Carew
PSA 8 Value $425Total PSA Population 4,130PSA 8 Population 483PSA 8 Grade Rate 11.7% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #12
1968 Topps #3 National League RBI Leaders
PSA 8 Value $275Total PSA Population 2,793PSA 8 Population 292PSA 8 Grade Rate 10.5% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #13
1968 Topps #100 Bob Gibson
PSA 8 Value $250Total PSA Population 3,627PSA 8 Population 693PSA 8 Grade Rate 19.1% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #14
1968 Topps #165 Tony Oliva
PSA 8 Value $250Total PSA Population 639PSA 8 Population 166PSA 8 Grade Rate 26.0% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #15
1968 Topps #374 Roberto Clemente All-Star
PSA 8 Value $250Total PSA Population 2,353PSA 8 Population 343PSA 8 Grade Rate 14.6% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #16
1968 Topps #5 National League Home Run Leaders
PSA 8 Value $225Total PSA Population 1,260PSA 8 Population 134PSA 8 Grade Rate 10.6% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #17
1968 Topps #355 Ernie Banks
PSA 8 Value $225Total PSA Population 3,739PSA 8 Population 721PSA 8 Grade Rate 19.3% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #18
1968 Topps #480 Managers Dream
PSA 8 Value $200Total PSA Population 3,040PSA 8 Population 584PSA 8 Grade Rate 19.2% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #19
1968 Topps #250 Carl Yastrzemski
PSA 8 Value $175Total PSA Population 3,892PSA 8 Population 763PSA 8 Grade Rate 19.6% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #20
1968 Topps #370 Hank Aaron All-Star
PSA 8 Value $175Total PSA Population 2,877PSA 8 Population 545PSA 8 Grade Rate 18.9% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #21
1968 Topps #500 Frank Robinson
PSA 8 Value $175Total PSA Population 1,839PSA 8 Population 385PSA 8 Grade Rate 20.9% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #22
1968 Topps #240 Al Kaline
PSA 8 Value $150Total PSA Population 2,632PSA 8 Population 471PSA 8 Grade Rate 17.9% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #23
1968 Topps #330 Roger Maris
PSA 8 Value $150Total PSA Population 3,927PSA 8 Population 792PSA 8 Grade Rate 20.2% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #24
1968 Topps #520 Lou Brock
PSA 8 Value $150Total PSA Population 2,334PSA 8 Population 749PSA 8 Grade Rate 32.1% (Set Avg: 29.8%) - #25
1968 Topps #290 Willie McCovey
PSA 8 Value $125Total PSA Population 2,193PSA 8 Population 577PSA 8 Grade Rate 26.3% (Set Avg: 29.8%)
Ross’s Take
So there you have it, the ten most valuable 1968 Topps baseball cards.
As you can see, this set is loaded with Hall of Famers and stars as well as some great rookie cards and variations.
This set was quite large as it contained a total of 598 cards.
High number cards, those numbered #498 to 598, were printed in smaller quantities and do carry price premiums versus other cards in the set.
Within the set were also several different subsets, including: All-Stars (#361 – 380) Leaders (#1 – 12) Star Rookies World Series Game 1-7 and Summary (#151 – 158) Checklists While the hobby may have mixed opinions on the aesthetic appeal of this set, there’s no doubting that it contains huge star power and great value overall.
