Sandy Koufax Baseball Cards: Values and Collector’s Guide

Topps followed up their 1955 release with another horizontal layout in 1956 that again featured a dual-image design.

This time, Koufax is featured in action along with his headshot.

Overall, the coloration of Koufax’s second-year card may seem a bit more dull than his rookie card but it’s a great-looking card, nonetheless.

Most Koufax collectors love his 1957 Topps issue for the fact that is simple and features a great head shot of the young Koufax with a big, bright smile on his face.

Centering and soft corners are usually what prevent most of these from being mint condition.

Those that do achieve the lofty grade can fetch upwards of $20,000 or more.

This would be the last time that Koufax would appear on a mainstream baseball card as a Brooklyn Dodger as the team would move to Los Angeles for the 1958 season.

The 1958 Topps issue was Koufax’s first card after the Dodgers moved from Brooklyn to Los Angeles even though he’s still pictured wearing a Brooklyn cap.

Other than that, there really isn’t much special about this card as it’s fairly basic with Koufax shown looking up and into the distance on a bright yellow background.

Koufax is finally sporting an L.A.

Dodgers hat in the 1959 Topps issue–not his most expensive but still a collector favorite.

You can see similar design characteristics between the 1958 and 1959 Topps issues but what really stands out is no doubt the encircled picture of Koufax and his bright smile.

Like the 1956 Topps cards, you can also see that the company brought back player signatures for the 1959 cards.

This was the year that Koufax finally broke out and started down the path of racking up his legendary achievements.

The 1961 Topps card itself shows a large picture of Koufax in a fielding position with his position and team information along the bottom.

Nothing special really but the 1961 Topps cards are still collector favorites.

Condition issues weren’t as prevalent as for others so you can find a mint copy of Koufax’s 1961 Topps card for under $1,000.

Either you love the wood grain borders on the 1962 Topps baseball cards or you don’t.

At the same time, those borders are usually what prevent these cards from achieving top grades as they are prone to showing chipping and wear more easily.

Mint copies of Koufax’s 1962 Topps card don’t pop up too often but when they do, you’ll usually see them sell in the low five figure range making them one of his more expensive cards.

Topps introduced a more complicated design in 1963 as its cards featured large images of players along the top with a smaller encircled call-out image of the player at the bottom.

It’s really a pretty sharp design overall and this is one of the more popular Sandy Koufax baseball cards among collectors.

Centering of the top image is usually an issue and you’ll frequently notice signs of chipping along the bottom colored section of the cards.

1963 was a monster year for Koufax while he was at his peak, taking home the Cy Young, triple crown of pitching, and MVP of both the World Series and regular season.

Seasons like that are what make legends out of baseball players.

It’s much easier to find 1964 Topps cards in good shape as the printing quality was much higher that year.

White borders help prevent chipping and wear from showing as easily and centering is usually not too big of a problem either.

Koufax’s 1964 Topps baseball card shows a big bright head shot image of him while “Dodgers” is printed in large, thick red lettering across the top.

Koufax didn’t take home the Cy Young in 1964 as it was an “off” year for him as his season was cut short due to injury.

He still managed to post 19 wins and 7 shutouts in 28 games.

The 1965 Topps Sandy Koufax baseball card shows a nice image of Koufax staring down a batter right before the pitch.

Nice rounded orange borders and a small blue pennant with the Dodgers team name along the bottom make this a very nice-looking card.

Centering can be a challenge and sometimes you’ll find some of the dreaded print bubbles in the orange bordering.

Koufax would pick up his second Cy Young and Triple Crown of Pitching awards in 1965.

That was also the same year he threw his perfect game and set a then record with 382 strikeouts in a single season.

Arthritis in his elbow would force 1966 to be Koufax’s last year in Major League Baseball at only age 30.

That last season would see Koufax win his most games in a single season (27) while posting his lowest single season ERA (1.73).

Who knows what kind of career stats he could have produced if he could have pitched longer?

The design of his 1966 Topps baseball card was fairly straightforward as it featured a large head shot with a serious look on his face, Dodgers team name in the upper left corner with his name and position at the bottom.