1

16 Most Valuable Derek Jeter Rookie Cards

Derek Jeter Playing Baseball

With so many great ones to choose from, how can you pick just one favorite Derek Jeter rookie card?

For me, when it comes to modern cards it comes down to value...

There are so many great designs on this list, but as a collector I always have value in the back of my mind.

So, I started wondering which of his rookie cards are his most valuable and I came up with this list after analyzing sales prices.

I know that many of the cards on this list are from 1992 and those are considered pre-rookies.

And, I also know the hobby recognizes only about 8 of his cards from 1993 to be actual rookie cards.

But I decided to mix and match anyway and toss cards from 1992 and 1993 all in this same list because it was more fun that way.

Without further ado, here are the 16 most valuable Derek Jeter rookie cards you can buy.

Why 16? Why not?

Let's jump right in...

More...

Ross Uitts

Ross Uitts - Owner

Need help selling sports cards?

If you need help selling sports cards but aren't sure where to start, click the button below to learn how I can help!

1993 SP #279

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $70,000

In 2015, these used to sell for around $30,000 in PSA 10 condition but three years later in May of 2018 one actually sold for a staggering $99,100. Two more sold later in 2018 for $76,105 and $73,300 so the price does seem to have cooled off a bit. Still, this card in PSA 10 condition easily remains one of the most expensive modern baseball cards you can find. The card itself is not scarce but finding one in pristine condition is extremely rare due to the ease of which the foil front chips. This iconic Jeter rookie helped launch Upper Deck's SP line of higher quality cards and is a firm collector favorite. Over time, this card could climb to the list of most valuable baseball cards if it stays consistently above $75,000 or so.

1993 SP #279 Derek Jeter Rookie Card

1992 Little Sun High School Prospects Auto

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $5,000

A sign of the times of how cards were being massively printed from all angles during the early 1990's, here we actually have a card with Jeter from his high school days in Kalamazoo, Michigan. His non-autographed version is also on this list but it's his autographed version that can go for thousands of dollars in PSA 10 condition. Only 250 autographed versions were printed so they're extremely rare, especially in PSA 10 condition.

1992 Little Sun High School Prospects Derek Jeter Baseball Card Autographed

1993 Upper Deck #449 Gold Hologram

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $1,600

At first glance, this may look like an ordinary 1993 Upper Deck Jeter card. But, if you look at the Upper Deck hologram in the lower left corner of the reverse side of the card, you can clearly see it's a golden color as opposed to the regular silver version. These gold parallels were only distributed in one out of every fifteen factory sets. So, they're extremely scarce compared to the silver hologram versions distributed in packs and the other fourteen out of fifteen factory sets. 

1993 Upper Deck #449 Derek Jeter Golden Hologram Baseball Card
1993 Upper Deck #449 Derek Jeter Golden Hologram Baseball Card Reverse Side

1992 Front Row Gold #55

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $1,300

Front Row was one of the first to introduce the idea of the multi-color parallels that you commonly see today. This set featured five different versions of this card: a base, gold, silver, purple promotional, and autographed versions. His most expensive, the gold version, shows the same photo used in the Little Sun set mentioned previously and you can easily see the golden features along the top. You could only find these in one of 5,000 factory sets.

1992 Front Row Gold #55 Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1993 Topps Micro #98

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $1,250

The 1993 Topps Micro Derek Jeter card is one of the strangest on this list. It's nothing more than a downsized, 1" x 1-3/8" version of the regular 1993 Topps Jeter card. Below, you can get an idea of scale of the micro version compared to the regular version. Personally, I'd be very nervous about buying one given how the PSA holder doesn't really look like it would do a good job of protecting it. Just look at the image below and you can imagine it slipping and sliding around in the holder just begging for a corner ding or two. 

1993 Topps Micro #98 Derek Jeter Baseball Card Graded PSA 10
1993 Topps #98 Derek Jeter Baseball Card Graded PSA 10

1992 Classic Four Sport Autographs #231

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $1,000

Next up is what I believe is one of Jeter's best-looking cards on this list. The action shot of the high school prospect makes this card instantly standout. And his hand-numbered autograph out of 1,125 adds a solid touch, too. His Little Sun autograph may be more expensive, and I get that since it's more rare, but in terms of eye appeal this one blows the other out of the water.

1992 Classic Four Sport Autographs #231 Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1992 Fleer Pro Cards Gulf Coast Yankees

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $1,000

This is one of the first cards in which you'll see Jeter in a Yankees uniform, albeit from his time with the Gulf Coast Yankees, the rookie affiliate of the New York Yankees. It's a really sharp-looking card showing Jeter likely doing what we'd see him do so many times throughout his career: throwing someone out at first. The colored borders make the card susceptible wear and tear making high grade specimens tough to come by.

1992 Fleer Pro Cards Gulf Coast Yankees Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1993 Topps #98 Colorad​​​​o Rockies Inaugural Year

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $1,000

This parallel to the base 1993 Topps card was part of a very limited run of factory sets distributed at Mile High Stadium and select stores in the Denver area. This gold embossed version is also easily distinguished by the emblem in the lower right corner. These limited sets were a great way to welcome the Rockies into MLB and these particular Jeter cards have and like will continue to steadily rise in value.

1993 Topps Colorado Rockies Inaugural Year #98 Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1992 Little Sun High School Prospects

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $950

The other Jeter card from the 1992 Little Sun set shows Jeter in his Kalamazoo high school uniform ready at short. The pink and green multi-color lettering along the bottom was a sign of the times. Not as valuable as the autographed version, this card can still command top dollar.

1992 Little Sun High School Prospects Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1992 Front Row Silver #55

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $850

There's really not much else to say about this silver parallel of the 1992 Front Row card other than there were 10,000 of these distributed inside factory sets. I'll never forget, someone actually got me one of the base sets for my birthday when I was a kid and I kept it sealed for a couple decades. I sent in my Jeter to PSA and it came back a 9 so I couldn't complain. Also interesting to note was that Jason Giambi was in this set, too.

1992 Front Row Silver #55 Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1993 Classic Best Auto #AU4

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $700

Jeter had four different 1993 Classic Best cards in total, one of which is this autographed version. Each of them is hand-numbered out of 1,200 and feature Jeter's signature in big blue ink. The card itself shows a great action shot of a young Jeter taking a nice cut.

1993 Classic Best Autographs #AU4 Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1993 Topps #98 Florida Marlins Inaugural Year

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $650

Not quite as expensive as the Colorado Rockies Inaugural Year version, the 1993 Topps Florida Marlins Inaugural Year is still special in its own right. Also limited in distribution, these versions easily standout with the emblem in the lower left corner. So, why aren't they as expensive as their Colorado Rockies counterparts? There are more than double the amount of these graded in PSA 10 condition.

1993 Topps Florida Marlins Inaugural Year #98 Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1993 Classic Best #1 Greensboro Hornets

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $600

Classic Best also issued a 30 card Greensboro Hornets set and wisely placed the young superstar as card number 1. The card features a great close-up image of Jeter posing as if following through a swing. These cards are hard to come by in any condition but if you're looking for PSA 10 quality then you'll have to pay up for one.

1993 Classic Best #1 Derek Jeter Greensboro Hornets Baseball Card

1993 Fleer Pro Cards All-Star #21

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $500

I always had a soft spot for Fleer and think they had some great designs over the years. And I think that's definitely the case with Jeter's 1993 Fleer Pro Cards South Atlantic League All-Star card. That's a mouthful to say and it will cost you a handful of cash to buy one of these in PSA 10 condition.

1993 Fleer Pro Cards South Atlantic League All-Star #21 Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1992 Classic C3 #4

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $450

Next on the list is yet another offering from Classic. As you can imagine, these cards can easily show wear and tear because of the dark blue borders. A young Jeter looks ready to react to a just-hit ball in this nice action shot of the budding superstar. I always thought the gold foil trim on this card added a nice design touch.

1992 Classic C3 #4 Derek Jeter Baseball Card

1993 Front Row Gold #2

Estimated PSA 10 Value: $350

Front Row came back in 1993 to offer this card of a young Jeter that's got much stronger eye appeal than their 1992 offering. Which isn't hard to do. You could have put any action shot on here and it would have been better than that yearbook picture they used in 1992. But, I'm not dogging on either of them too hard, either of these cards are great to own for any Jeter fan.

1993 Front Row Gold #2 Derek Jeter Baseball Card

Derek Jeter's Legacy

I absolutely idolized Derek Jeter growing up.

I played shortstop up through high school and looked up to him, how he carried himself and how he played the game.

For all of his great accomplishments, I always put how good of a ballplayer Jeter was into perspective by asking this question: "If you had to create a Mt. Rushmore of New York Yankees, who would you leave off a list of Babe Ruth, Lou Gehrig, Joe DiMaggio, Mickey Mantle, and Derek Jeter?"

Some people may easily cast aside Jeter but I don't think it's that easy...

The all-time Yankees hit leader (3,465)--not to mention other Yankees records--would also go on to achieve the following:

  • AL Rookie of the Year (1996)
  • 14x All-Star
  • 5x World Series Champion
  • 5x Gold Glove
  • 5x Silver Slugger
  • 2x Hank Aaron Award
  • 1x Roberto Clemente Award

One of the things that has always stood out to me was that Jeter never won an MVP award.

And when I look at his stat lines, I get it...the numbers were never quite there.

So, how can a guy who never won an MVP be considered part of a Yankees Mt. Rushmore?

Somehow he was just bigger than numbers...

Ross Uitts
 

Ross is the founder of Old Sports Cards and has been collecting sports cards for over 30 years. He also loves to write about the hobby and has written for Beckett, Topps, SABR and of course, this website. Need help buying or selling cards or have a general question about the hobby? Contact him at [email protected]

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 1 comments