25 Most Valuable 1991 Fleer Baseball Cards
I will always remember the 1991 Fleer baseball card set for one simple reason: it was the first factory set I ever owned.
My grandpa purchased the factory set at a flea market one year and gave it to me as a birthday present.
To this day, I still have it in my possession…
While monetarily it’s not worth anymore today than when he bought it all those years ago, it will always fill me with nostalgia and fantastic memories of my grandpa and early collecting days.
In all, the 1991 Fleer set wasn’t well-received by collectors as it lacked star rookie power and its design was considered to be underwhelming.
Regardless, in this guide, I’ll run through the 25 most valuable to look for.
Let’s jump right in!
1991 Fleer Baseball Set Snapshot
SET DETAILS
TOTAL CARDS
720
KEY ROOKIES
No Significant Rookies
KEY VETERANS
Ken Griffey Jr., Nolan Ryan, Rickey Henderson, Cal Ripken Jr., Tony Gwynn, Ryne Sandberg
GRADING ANALYSIS
8,636
TOTAL GRADED BY PSA
3,265
PSA 10 Population
37.8%
PSA 10 Grade Rate
MOST GRADED CARDS
1
#710 Barry Bonds/Ken Griffey Jr.
22.6%
1,951
2
#450 Ken Griffey Jr. Bat .300
10.4%
899
3
#302 Nolan Ryan
8.8%
756
PREVIOUS SET
NEXT SET
Love old cards? Get weekly updates from a fellow collector!
Weekly pricing updates, grading insights, and new card guides — straight to your inbox. For free.
Join thousands of collectors. Unsubscribe anytime.

Ross Uitts – Owner
- #1
1991 Fleer #710 Second Generation Stars
PSA 10 Value $410 – $420Total PSA Population 1,951PSA 10 Population 268PSA 10 Grade Rate 13.7% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Bobby Bonds and Ken Griffey Sr. each had very respectable MLB careers and each would go on to make 3 All-Star appearances.
However, it was their sons who were two of the hottest and most promising young stars back in 1991 when Fleer created this “Second Generation Stars” card to commemorate them.
The card packs terrific eye appeal with its horizontal layout, bright yellow borders and bright smiles on the superstars’ faces.
While at the time they were both on a Hall of Fame trajectory, only Griffey Jr. would make it as Bonds’ career ended in controversy due to the PED scandal.
Though their legacies turned out very different, having both of these superstars on the same card gives it enough boost to take the top slot on this liSt.
- #2
1991 Fleer #302 Nolan Ryan
PSA 10 Value $130 – $135Total PSA Population 756PSA 10 Population 267PSA 10 Grade Rate 35.3% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Even though he was clearly on the backend of his career in 1991, Ryan was still able to pitch effectively for the Rangers that season.
In fact, he was a 12-game winner and put up a respectable 2.91 ERA while striking out 203 batters.
Oh, and don’t forget…he also tossed his seventh career no-hitter in May that season against the Blue Jays.
Ryan was notorious for his blazing fastball but Fleer captured him perfectly in this image throwing his circle changeup, a pitch he threw only 14% of the time.
- #3
1991 Fleer #450 Ken Griffey Jr.
PSA 10 Value $100 – $105Total PSA Population 142PSA 10 Population 60PSA 10 Grade Rate 42.3% (Set Avg: 37.8%)The fact that Griffey’s third-year card is in the number two slot for this set speaks volumes of its lack of star rookie power.
And I’m not trying to take anything away from him–he was always among the top names of any set of the late ’80s and early ’90s.
But, neither Jeff Bagwell, Ivan Rodriguez nor Mike Mussina would appear until the 1991 Fleer Update was released.
And Chipper Jones wasn’t in either the 1991 Fleer or Fleer Update set, for that matter.
I always wished that Fleer would’ve grabbed a better image for this card as it looks like Griffey has just popped out rather than hitting a towering homer.
Finally, there are two variations of this card: one that states on the back that, in 1990, Griffey would blossom and “bat around .300” and one that he would “bat .300”.
There are about three times as many “bat .300” variations in PSA 10 holders so there is a bit of a price premium on the “bat around .300” variation.
- #4
1991 Fleer #561 Bo Jackson
PSA 10 Value $65 – $66Total PSA Population 364PSA 10 Population 112PSA 10 Grade Rate 30.8% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Was any athlete hotter than Bo Jackson during the late ’80s and ’90s?
Maybe Michael Jordan…but not many others.
Jackson’s popularity soared due to his two-sport stardom, Nike advertising campaigns and unstoppable presence on Nintendo’s Tecmo Bowl.
To this day, I love watching old highlights of Jackson throwing people out with his cannon of an arm.
But Jackson could absolutely crush the ball, too, as he’s clearly about to do in this shot of him in his Kansas City Royals uniform.
- #5
1991 Fleer #33 Barry Bonds
PSA 10 Value $62 – $63Total PSA Population 302PSA 10 Population 113PSA 10 Grade Rate 37.4% (Set Avg: 37.8%)It took both a batting title and a sudden franchise revival in 1991 to stop Barry Bonds’ repeat bid for NL MVP.
Today, the pendulum would have undoubtedly swung Bonds’ way.
The Pittsburgh Pirates left fielder was the most complete player in the National League, topping the circuit in WAR (8.0) for a second consecutive season.
MVP winner Atlanta’s Terry Pendleton finished tied for third (6.1).
Now, voters didn’t consider WAR in ’91.
Yet, there’s no denying Bonds’ 25 home runs, 43 stolen bases, and league-leading marks in on-base percentage (.410), OPS (.924), and OPS+ (160).
Oh yeah, throw in a second consecutive Gold Glove and back-to-back Silver Slugger honors.
Ultimately, the NL MVP race came down to who had the better story.
Pendleton won his first batting crown (.319) and led the Braves from the bottom of the NL East to a league pennant.
That was just enough to edge out Bonds, twelve first-place votes to ten.
- #6
1991 Fleer #673 Don Mattingly
PSA 10 Value $55 – $56Total PSA Population 190PSA 10 Population 78PSA 10 Grade Rate 41.1% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Throughout the 1980s it seemed like Don Mattingly was well on his way to being that next great Yankee to be enshrined in the Hall of Fame like those before him.
He was routinely appearing in All-Star games as well as racking up Gold Gloves and Silver Slugger awards.
He even had an MVP and batting title to his name.
However, injuries started to catch up to him and his ability to hit for power nose-dived in the 1990s.
But while Mattingly’s career tailed off towards the end, his nostalgic factor is still there for collectors who grew up collecting in the junk era.
- #7
1991 Fleer #5 Jose Canseco
PSA 10 Value $50 – $51Total PSA Population 99PSA 10 Population 30PSA 10 Grade Rate 30.3% (Set Avg: 37.8%)The Jose Canseco sideshow became a full-blown carnival in 1991.
The 26-year-old Oakland A’s right fielder put up numbers befitting the game’s most dangerous sluggers, slashing .266/.359/.556 and tying Cecil Fielder for the MLB home run title with 44.
Canseco also swiped 26 bases while placing second in the AL in both runs scored (115) and RBIs (122).
The A’s fell short of back-to-back-to-back-to-back AL pennants with a fourth-place finish, but Canseco still clocked in fourth in the AL MVP race.
So, why exactly was the Oakland front office entertaining trade rumors for one of the game’s most recognizable superstars?
Part of it was the usual A’s cost-cutting measures.
Part of it was Canseco’s constant tabloid controversies, including a he-said/she-said romance with Madonna that cast a constant shadow over anything the team did in ’91.
Months after that blew over, Canseco was charged with aggravated battery for reportedly ramming his wife’s car with his Porsche.
- #8
1991 Fleer #431 Ryne Sandberg
PSA 10 Value $50 – $51Total PSA Population 125PSA 10 Population 65PSA 10 Grade Rate 52.0% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Ryne Sandberg’s name sometimes gets lost in the shuffle of other marquee names.
It shouldn’t.
From 1990 to 1992, the Chicago Cubs second baseman won two Gold Gloves, three Silver Sluggers, and made three of his ten career All-Star appearances.
Despite limited protection from a lineup and overall team that hovered around 77 to 78 wins, Sandberg posted a beefy 21.9 WAR over that stretch.
Only two players eclipsed that number: the great Cal Ripken Jr. and Barry Bonds.
1991 was the weakest of the three in terms of WAR (7.0) and OPS+ (138), but not by much.
The 31-year-old hit to a .291/.379/.485 slash with 26 home runs, 32 doubles, 104 runs, 87 walks, 22 stolen bases, and 100 RBIs in 158 games.
It wasn’t the 40-homer barrage of a year prior, but it was still among the most complete and dazzling performances of the campaign.
- #9
1991 Fleer #713 Chicago Cubs 100 Club
PSA 10 Value $48 – $49Total PSA Population 103PSA 10 Population 47PSA 10 Grade Rate 45.6% (Set Avg: 37.8%) - #10
1991 Fleer #10 Rickey Henderson
PSA 10 Value $46 – $47Total PSA Population 159PSA 10 Population 85PSA 10 Grade Rate 53.5% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Most Rickey Henderson cards show the speedster either in the middle of swiping a bag or in his compact hitting stance.
However, this one shows Rickey headed back to safety trying not to get picked off while leading off the base.
To my knowledge, a baserunner being picked off is not counted in the “caught stealing” category, of which Henderson is the all-time MLB leader.
I can’t imagine it happened too frequently to him, however.
This is just one of those images that captures the true essence of a legend like Rickey and an opposing team trying to prevent him from wreaking havoc on them.
It may be an odd action shot but I really like it…
- #11
1991 Fleer #161 Darryl Strawberry
PSA 10 Value $41 – $42Total PSA Population 93PSA 10 Population 36PSA 10 Grade Rate 38.7% (Set Avg: 37.8%)1991 was the last year before Darryl Strawberry’s fall.
The wagons of addiction, tax problems, and mental health issues were already circling when Strawberry signed his five-year, $20.25 million free-agent deal with the Los Angeles Dodgers.
However, he had at least one All-Star campaign to give them.
Named to his eighth Midsummer Classic, the 29-year-old right fielder slashed .265/.361/.491 with 28 home runs, 22 doubles, ten stolen bases, 86 runs, 75 walks, and 99 RBIs in 139 games.
His outfield play was beginning to suffer, but his 140 OPS+ still reflected a top-ten caliber hitter.
Strawberry finished ninth for MVP, marking his fourth top-nine placement in five years.
It was the quintessential last hurrah.
The troubled superstar played just 75 more games for Los Angeles over the next two seasons as injuries and alcohol abuse reared their ugly heads.
After that, he averaged just 43.3 games a year over the six years leading to his 1999 retirement.
- #12
1991 Fleer #426 Greg Maddux
PSA 10 Value $40 – $41Total PSA Population 89PSA 10 Population 59PSA 10 Grade Rate 66.3% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Greg Maddux was like Swiss clockwork.
He was precise, refined in his approach, and extremely durable.
1991 was Maddux’s penultimate year with the Chicago Cubs.
While it wasn’t on par with his 1989 breakout and nowhere near what he was about to achieve, it gave us a glimpse of just how reliable “The Professor” really was.
Maddux completed seven of his MLB-high 37 starts, leading all NL hurlers in innings for the first of five consecutive campaigns.
Not only that, but the 25-year-old righty also clocked 1,070 batters faced, the first of four straight campaigns that he topped the Senior Circuit.
Overall, Maddux finished 15-11 with a 3.35 ERA.
He barely missed 200 strikeouts (198) and issued only 66 walks.
In truth, ’91 was just a teaser.
Maddux rattled off four consecutive Cy Youngs from ’92 to ’95, becoming the first pitcher in MLB history to do so.
- #13
1991 Fleer #646 Ozzie Smith
PSA 10 Value $39 – $41Total PSA Population 72PSA 10 Population 45PSA 10 Grade Rate 62.5% (Set Avg: 37.8%)The St. Louis Cardinals bounced back from a dreadful last-place finish in 1990 to the periphery of a pennant race in 1991.
As you might expect, a lot of that had to do with “The Wizard” Ozzie Smith.
Smith had the best offensive season by OPS+ of his career (112), seven points better than his 1987 MVP runner-up campaign.
The 37-year-old shortstop posted a .285/.380/.367 slash line with three home runs, 30 doubles, 35 stolen bases, 83 walks, 96 runs, and 50 RBIs in 150 games.
He also exhibited great patience (as always), striking out just 36 times in 641 plate appearances.
Somehow, we went this long without discussing Smith’s all-around defense, but yeah, that was there too.
He led all NL shortstops in fielding percentage (.987) for a seventh time while turning a league-best 79 double plays.
The first-ballot Hall-of-Famer also committed a career-low eight errors in 639 chances, making him a cinch for his 12th consecutive Gold Glove.
- #14
1991 Fleer #490 Cal Ripken Jr.
PSA 10 Value $37 – $38Total PSA Population 201PSA 10 Population 111PSA 10 Grade Rate 55.2% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Cal Ripken Jr. was one of, if not the greatest, shortstops who ever played the game.
From 1983 to his retirement after the 2001 season, he appeared in an incredible 19-straight All-Star games.
With so many great seasons under his belt, you’d think it would be impossible for one particular season to stand above the rest as his greateSt. Well, it turns out that the 1991 season was likely his greatest as he set career highs in home runs (32) and RBI (114) on his way to earning MVP, Gold Glove and Silver Slugger honors.
Like the shot of him scooping up the ball on this card, Ripken was scooping up all the awards that year…
- #15
1991 Fleer #138 Frank Thomas
PSA 10 Value $35 – $36Total PSA Population 317PSA 10 Population 119PSA 10 Grade Rate 37.5% (Set Avg: 37.8%)I think this is one of the best-looking cards in the entire set as Frank Thomas is shown taking a huge rip at the ball in that awesome retro Sox jersey.
Everyone knows that Thomas was a gigantic human being…but this card somehow makes him look even bigger.
Since he appeared in the 1990 Fleer Update set the year before, this is considered his second-year Fleer issue.
Thomas wasted no time getting to work in the Big Leagues as he would smack 32 homers, drive in 109 RBI and bat .318 on his way to winning the Silver Slugger award and finishing third in MVP voting in 1991.
- #16
1991 Fleer #623 Kirby Puckett
PSA 10 Value $35 – $36Total PSA Population 99PSA 10 Population 65PSA 10 Grade Rate 65.7% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Another fantastic ballplayer of the era and easy fan favorite, Kirby Puckett rounds out our liSt. While he only played in 12 seasons, Puckett was consistently one of the best in the game as he appeared in 10 All-Star games, won 6 Gold Gloves and Silver Sluggers, and helped the Twins win 2 World Series.
To say the least, Puckett could play.
And he clearly loved doing so as you’d almost always see him with a huge smile on his face.
- #17
1991 Fleer #601 Robin Yount
PSA 10 Value $31 – $32Total PSA Population 59PSA 10 Population 43PSA 10 Grade Rate 72.9% (Set Avg: 37.8%) - #18
1991 Fleer #90 Roger Clemens
PSA 10 Value $31 – $32Total PSA Population 107PSA 10 Population 56PSA 10 Grade Rate 52.3% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Roger Clemens is as close to a slam-dunk pick as you’ll find when discussing the greatest right-handed pitchers of all time.
He was also legendary at shooting himself in the foot.
In 1991, the Boston Red Sox super-ace captured his third of seven career Cy Youngs and was a few bullpen hiccups away from an AL Triple Crown.
The 28-year-old topped the Junior Circuit in a wide swath of categories, including ERA (2.62), innings pitched (an MLB-best 271.1), strikeouts (an MLB-best 241), shutouts (4), and ERA+ (an MLB-best 161).
Clemens’ seven Cy Youngs are an MLB record, and he’s one of just three pitchers (Greg Maddux, Sandy Koufax) with multiple trophies before age 30.
Oh, but there’s all the other stuff, too.
Clemens is, obviously, outside of Cooperstown looking in because of his steroid connections.
Yet, he was also a mercurial, hard-headed, hard-to-understand guy who landed in hot water multiple times, including a 1991 arrest on charges of assaulting an off-duty police officer in defense of his brother, Gary.
- #19
1991 Fleer #552 George Brett
PSA 10 Value $29 – $30Total PSA Population 155PSA 10 Population 106PSA 10 Grade Rate 68.4% (Set Avg: 37.8%)The Kansas City Royals wanted the great George Brett’s bat in the lineup as long as humanly possible.
That’s why they moved the 13-time All-Star from his trademark corner-infield role to designated hitter before the 1991 season.
Brett wasn’t thrilled with the new assignment, but understood it.
His defense was hampered by recurring knee issues, even with the full-time shift from third to first base in 1987.
If the Royals wanted to maximize his offensive contributions while minimizing his defensive liabilities, this was the only move that made sense.
The problem, in retrospect, was that the results weren’t exactly what anyone expected.
Brett’s hitting took a massive dip in 1991 after his top-seven MVP finish the year before, a .255/.327/.402 slash with ten homers, 61 RBIs, a 101 OPS+, and 0.4 WAR in 131 games.
Reducing his defensive load to ten contests seemed like the right idea, but it also appeared to disrupt his routine and reduce his overall impact.
- #20
1991 Fleer #17 Mark McGwire
PSA 10 Value $29 – $30Total PSA Population 127PSA 10 Population 57PSA 10 Grade Rate 44.9% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Mark McGwire’s 1991 season was “awful” by his own admission.
However, he was blown away by the pointed criticism he faced.
“From what I heard, people thought I was done,” McGwire said before the next campaign.
“I had four great years and one bad one, and people thought I was done.” The truth was that McGwire’s personal life was bleeding into his professional life.
A 1990 breakup tore him apart privately, and the turmoil followed him on and off the field.
According to McGwire, he jumped into therapy for four years after this to process things and move forward.
The hulking slugger kept quiet about much of this in ’91, though, and became cannon fodder for angry fans as the season progressed.
McGwire hit just .201 with 22 home runs and 75 RBIs in 154 games for the fourth-place Athletics.
His average was below the Mendoza Line as late as August 6th, and it may have slipped there by season’s end if he had played one or two more games.
- #21
1991 Fleer #409 Dale Murphy
PSA 10 Value $28 – $29Total PSA Population 78PSA 10 Population 55PSA 10 Grade Rate 70.5% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Rewind to the early 1980s, and Dale Murphy looked like a no-doubt Hall of Famer.
The power-hitting Atlanta Braves outfielder became just the ninth player in MLB history to win back-to-back MVPs in 1982 and 1983, and followed that up with back-to-back NL home run titles in 1984 and 1985.
And then, it all spiraled.
Murphy’s lengthy list of knee issues, plus a scary bout of MRSA, zapped his power and cost him long stretches of games.
In 1987, he was a legitimate MVP candidate for most of the year.
In 1988, he was a league-average hitter with no going back.
By 1991, it all felt like a cruel joke.
At least Murphy played a full season that year, though.
In his only non-injury-shortened campaign with Philadelphia, the 35-year-old hit .252 in 153 games and ranked second on the team behind All-Star John Kruk in home runs (18) and RBIs (81).
- #22
1991 Fleer #529 Tony Gwynn
PSA 10 Value $28 – $29Total PSA Population 115PSA 10 Population 67PSA 10 Grade Rate 58.3% (Set Avg: 37.8%)Tony Gwynn went four years between NL batting titles from 1990 to 1993, but those weren’t exactly down years for the San Diego Padres legend.
Gwynn placed eighth, third, fifth, and second in the National League in those four years chronologically, extending his streak of top-eight batting crown finishes to a full decade.
He would ultimately extend this National League-record run to a remarkable fourteen in a row.
It’s wild to look at Gwynn’s age-31 season in 1991 and shrug.
After all, it was a lower-tier performance compared to the rest of his first-ballot Hall-of-Fame resume.
The numbers and accolades, however, were anything but blah.
Gwynn made his seventh All-Star team and won his fourth Gold Glove in ’91 while placing third in the NL in average (.317), second in triples (11), tenth in hits (168), second in dWAR (2.6), and fifth in position-player WAR (5.7).
- #23
1991 Fleer #455 Randy Johnson
PSA 10 Value $27 – $28Total PSA Population 80PSA 10 Population 34PSA 10 Grade Rate 42.5% (Set Avg: 37.8%)When grizzled Texas Rangers ace Nolan Ryan watched a young Randy Johnson pitch in the early 1990s, he saw a lot of himself.
“He was a lot like me when I was younger,” Ryan said.
“He was just pitching and not doing a lot of thinking.” Ryan didn’t have Johnson’s size, but he had the same control problems, at least for a while.
The 27-year wonder topped the league in walks allowed eight times before getting a handle on things later in his career.
Johnson was in a similar boat.
After pacing the Majors with 120 walks allowed in 1990, his free passes ballooned to a career-worst 152 in 1991.
He was tinkering with a slider at this point, but he had yet to find a way to mark the strike zone with it consistently.
The 27-year-old Seattle Mariners hurler concluded the year at 13-10 with a 3.98 ERA in 201.1 innings.
His 228 strikeouts placed second to Boston’s Roger Clemens (241).
- #24
1991 Fleer #86 Wade Boggs
PSA 10 Value $26 – $27Total PSA Population 44PSA 10 Population 27PSA 10 Grade Rate 61.4% (Set Avg: 37.8%)It may not have been on the level of the untouchable Ty Cobb, but Wade Boggs’ decade of .300 seasons was an instant Hall-of-Fame pass.
The superstar Boston Red Sox third baseman posted at least a .302 average in every campaign from 1982 to 1991, winning five batting crowns along the way.
He’d add five more .300 seasons before his retirement, placing him in a five-way tie for 15th all-time with fifteen overall.
1991 was the last of the bunch, and it came with some interesting statistical add-ons.
The 33-year-old finished runner-up behind batting champ Willie Randolph with a .332 average and placed third in on-base percentage (.421).
However, he also had some major hiccups in the clutch, grounding into a league- and career-high 25 double plays.
Regardless, you can’t knock a decade of .300 performances, even if it falls 13 years short of Ty Cobb’s unassailable record.
- #25
1991 Fleer #259 Will Clark
PSA 10 Value $23 – $24Total PSA Population 36PSA 10 Population 22PSA 10 Grade Rate 61.1% (Set Avg: 37.8%)San Francisco Giants first baseman Will Clark called his shot in August 1991.
“You can have all the offensive awards there are,” Clark said.
“I want the defensive award.
I want the Gold Glove.” At that point, Clark had more marketable plaudits in sight.
After all, he was a dark-horse MVP candidate and very much in the running for the NL home run title.
However, Clark expected himself to be in the mix for MVPs and home run crowns.
He never lacked for confidence, especially at his late-80s, early-90s peak.
Clark was more obsessed with being a complete player, doing everything to help the team win.
And the way to put that over the top, for him, was to play S-tier defense at firSt. Ironically, he cemented his first (and only) Gold Glove for a ’91 Giants team that lost 30 of its final 50 games, closing out the season a distant fourth in the NL WeSt.

Ross’s Take
So there you have it, the 25 most valuable 1991 Fleer baseball cards.
Most of the cards in the set are worthless and none of them really make sense to have professionally graded as even the values of the top cards in PSA 10 condition don’t justify it.
Many collectors, like myself, still do have a bit of nostalgia for the set, though.
And whether you love or hate the 720-card set, it did contain some recognizable subsets and inserts, including: SuperStar Specials Checklists All-Stars Pro-Visions World Series Team Logo Stickers
Love old cards? Get weekly updates from a fellow collector.
Pricing updates, grading insights, and new guides on the cards you actually care about — the junk wax era, vintage, and everything in between. One email a week. No fluff.
Free. No spam. Unsubscribe anytime.

Ross Uitts – Owner