25 Most Valuable 1974 Topps Baseball Cards
With Hank Aaron finishing the 1973 season just one home run shy of Babe Ruth’s career record, the 1974 Topps baseball card set jumped at the chance to highlight history.
Topps used the first six cards in the 660-card checklist to pay tribute to Hammerin’ Hank by crowning him the “New All-Time Home Run King” with card #1 and showcasing his previous Topps cards on cards #2-6.
Actually, there are 678 cards in the set if you count the cards made for Padres players playing in Washington that Topps scrapped after the team’s plans to move fell through…
But that’s another story altogether.
This set played a huge role in celebrating Aaron’s upcoming historic achievement.
Topps also helped collectors get their hands on every card in the checklist faster than usual in a couple of ways:
- by releasing them at once rather than in multiple series for the first time in company history
- by producing its first-ever factory set available for order via JC Penny’s store catalog
The 1974 Topps set packed plenty of history and many great cards for collectors to enjoy.
And in this guide, we’ll take a look at the 10 most valuable.
Let’s jump right in!
1974 Topps Baseball: Market Analysis and Value Guide
1974 Topps Baseball Set Snapshot
1974 Topps Grading Analysis
-
1974 Topps #1 Hank Aaron
PSA 9 Value: $3,750
Total PSA Population: 5,090
PSA 9 Population: 118
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 2.3% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
On April 8, 1974, Hank Aaron’s pursuit of Babe Ruth’s all-time home run record ended in front of 53,775 fans in Atlanta.
He had finished the 1973 season one shy of the Babe at 713 home runs, so you can imagine the emotion and excitement that built up during the offseason.
Aaron stayed on that total for one at-bat in 1974, tying Ruth on April 4 in Cincinnati with a shot off Reds pitcher Jack Billingham.
And on April 8, he took Dodgers hurler Al Downing deep with a fourth-inning bomb.
A fan rushed on the field to congratulate Aaron as he rounded second base.
One of the most iconic moments in baseball history played out, shot for shot in real-time.
Aaron, 40, played in just 112 games in 1974, the lowest total of his 21-year career thus far, and slashed .268/.341/.491 with 20 home runs and 69 RBI.
He failed to surpass 100 hits for the first time and posted the lowest OPS of his career to that point (.832).
On October 2, Aaron hit his 733rd home run, his last with the Braves.
One month later, the Braves traded him to the Milwaukee Brewers, where he would begin his career swan song as a designated hitter.
-
1974 Topps #20 Nolan Ryan
PSA 9 Value: $2,200
Total PSA Population: 7,894
PSA 9 Population: 239
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 3.0% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
In 1973, California Angels ace Nolan Ryan became the fourth MLB pitcher to throw two no-hitters in a single season.
In 1974, he became the only Major Leaguer to toss three no-hitters in two seasons.
On September 28 against the Minnesota Twins, Ryan was an all-or-nothing spectacle, striking out fifteen and walking eight.
And after fanning Eric Soderholm, he secured his third career no-hitter (and a 4-0 complete game win) in front of a loud, sparse home crowd of 10,872.
It was Ryan’s career-best 22nd win of the season, remarkable considering he accounted for just under a third of the team’s 68 victories.
Ryan finished the year 22-16 with a 2.89 ERA with 26 complete games and led baseball with 332.2 innings pitched.
He also topped the Majors in strikeouts (367), hits per 9 innings (6.0), and strikeouts per 9 innings (9.9).
On the wild side, Ryan became the first pitcher since Bob Feller (1938) to issue 200 walks or more (202).
Ryan’s remarkable season earned him a third-place finish in the AL’s Cy Young balloting and a 14th-place finish in the AL MVP race.
-
1974 Topps #456 Dave Winfield Rookie Card
PSA 9 Value: $1,750
Total PSA Population: 10,632
PSA 9 Population: 487
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 4.6% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
Drafted 4th overall in the 1973 MLB June Amateur Draft by the San Diego Padres, future Hall-of-Fame slugger Dave Winfield was ready to start immediately.
Winfield signed for $15,000 and skipped the Minors altogether and, upon his arrival in San Diego, showed flashes of future greatness in 56 games on the 1973 season.
He also showed empathy beyond his years as he began buying blocks of tickets for underprivileged families.
Winfield continued his generosity in 1974 while blossoming into a legit threat in the batter’s box.
In 544 plate appearances (498 at-bats), Winfield posted a respectable .265/.318/.438 line with 20 home runs and 75 RBI.
He rapped eighteen doubles, four triples and stole nine bases while amassing an impressive 218 total bases.
On defense, the future seven-time Gold Glove winner showcased his athleticism at all three outfield positions.
Each day, he earned the respect of his peers and manager, John McNamara. “After the All-Star break, McNamara said to me, ‘Kid, I’m going to give you a chance to play every day. Play well and the job is yours,” Winfield said later.
He did play well and the job would be his in San Diego for nearly a decade.
-
1974 Topps #3800 Pete Rose
PSA 9 Value: $1,650
After his best all-around season and his only league MVP award in 1973, Pete Rose was due for a letdown.
In 1974, the Cincinnati Reds left fielder broke a nine-year streak of hitting .300 or better with a .284 average.
His .773 OPS was his worst since his sophomore season in 1964 and to top it off, he hit a career-low three home runs while driving in 51.
It was enough to prompt members of the press to wonder aloud if the 33-year-old hit machine had begun to lose a step.
But he hadn’t.
Rose showed up consistently, leading the league in plate appearances (771) for the third year in a row, and still produced enough to lead the Majors with 45 doubles and 110 runs scored.
Cincinnati had the second-best run-scoring offense in the National League, and Rose’s table-setting was a leading factor.
The Reds missed the playoffs by four games with a 98-64 record.
And many still pointed to Rose’s perceived drop in production as the reason why.
By the end of the next season, those criticisms would seem silly.
-
1974 Topps #300 Pete Rose
PSA 9 Value: $1,650
Total PSA Population: 4,061
PSA 9 Population: 149
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 3.7% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
After his best all-around season and his only league MVP award in 1973, Pete Rose was due for a letdown.
In 1974, the Cincinnati Reds left fielder broke a nine-year streak of hitting .300 or better with a .284 average.
His .773 OPS was his worst since his sophomore season in 1964 and to top it off, he hit a career-low three home runs while driving in 51.
It was enough to prompt members of the press to wonder aloud if the 33-year-old hit machine had begun to lose a step.
But he hadn’t.
Rose showed up consistently, leading the league in plate appearances (771) for the third year in a row, and still produced enough to lead the Majors with 45 doubles and 110 runs scored.
Cincinnati had the second-best run-scoring offense in the National League, and Rose’s table-setting was a leading factor.
The Reds missed the playoffs by four games with a 98-64 record.
And many still pointed to Rose’s perceived drop in production as the reason why.
By the end of the next season, those criticisms would seem silly.
-
1974 Topps #130 Reggie Jackson
PSA 9 Value: $1,500
Total PSA Population: 2,914
PSA 9 Population: 95
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 3.3% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
The 1974 Oakland Athletics were one of the most talented ballclubs in MLB history.
But, they were also one of the most dysfunctional.
Jackson clashed with teammates, particularly centerfielder Bill North, and tensions remained high all season.
Jackson’s mood worsened, leading to an incident where he angrily tossed a bat into the stands, just missing two young boys and manager Alvin Dark’s wife.
It was quite a time by the Bay.
Yet, the Athletics were still the class of the Majors, and Jackson was a huge part of their success.
In 604 plate appearances (506 at-bats), Jackson went .289/.391/.514 with 29 home runs and 93 RBI.
He also led the American League in OPS+ (166) and intentional walks (20), earning his fifth All-Star nod and a fourth-place finish in the AL’s MVP balloting.
Mr. October struggled in Oakland’s four-game ALCS triumph over the Baltimore Orioles, hitting just .167 with an RBI.
He picked it up against Los Angeles in the World Series, going 4-for-14 (.286) with a double, a home run, and five walks.
And in the clinching Game 5, a heads-up defensive play by Jackson helped secure the team’s 3-2 win.
A dynasty reached its coronation. And then, it was gone.
-
1974 Topps #252 Dave Parker Rookie Card
PSA 9 Value: $1,200
Total PSA Population: 4,128
PSA 9 Population: 252
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 6.1% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
Dave Parker’s wild ride of an MLB career was just getting started in 1974.
The hulking 23-year-old Pittsburgh Pirates outfielder entered his second professional season as a platoon option against right-handed pitching.
But, Parker was a year away from truly finding his power stroke as the left-handed slugger missed most of June and July on the disabled list due to a hamstring injury.
On the season, Parker played in just 73 games, batting .282/.322/.409 with four home runs and 29 RBI.
He was, admittedly, constricted by the platoon situation.
Yet, he showed enough in his 220 at-bats for Pirates manager Danny Murtaugh to lift the platoon designation the following season.
Parker responded by becoming one of the most feared hitters in all of baseball.
1974 was just the beginning and the real roller coaster was just catching speed at Three Rivers Stadium.
-
1974 Topps #10 Johnny Bench
PSA 9 Value: $1,000
Total PSA Population: 2,095
PSA 9 Population: 104
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 5.0% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
The 1974 Cincinnati Reds were on the precipice of something great, but nobody quite knew it yet.
Cincinnati had earned a reputation as a talented team that couldn’t get the job done, but this was no fault of star catcher Johnny Bench.
The 1972 National League MVP continued to boost his case as the Player of the 1970s with another fantastic campaign in 1974.
In 708 plate appearances (621 at-bats), Bench slashed .280/.363/.507 with 33 home runs and an MLB-best 129 RBI.
He also led the Majors with a whopping 315 total bases and posted the only 100-run season of his career (108).
Another trademark stellar season for Bench earned him his 7th-straight All-Star nod, his 7th-straight Gold Glove, and a 4th-place finish in the National League’s MVP balloting.
The Reds missed the playoffs for the first time since 1971, and questions began to mount as to whether the Big Red Machine would ever realize its potential.
Two years and two titles later, Bench and the Cincinnati Reds would silence their doubters and leap from disappointments to a dynasty.
-
1974 Topps #283 Mike Schmidt
PSA 9 Value: $850
Total PSA Population: 5,696
PSA 9 Population: 349
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 6.1% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
Mike Schmidt’s rookie season in 1973 was disappointing as he posted a meager .196 batting average and .697 in 132 games played.
Not to be deterred, the Philadelphia Phillies’ third baseman put in plenty of work to correct his hitting issues during the offseason.
The hard work paid off, as Schmidt broke out in 1974, hitting .282 and leading the National League with a .546 slugging percentage.
He also led the Majors with 36 home runs, drove in 116, scored 108 runs, and walked 106 times.
He did continue to struggle against off-speed stuff out of the zone, though, as he struck out an MLB-worst 138 times, the first of three straight seasons where he’d pace the Majors in whiffs.
Meanwhile, Schmidt’s soon-to-be-legendary glove was on display as his 404 assists in 1974 is still an MLB record for a third baseman.
The Phillies finished third in the NL East with an 80-82 record, but optimism was easy to come by since it was the first time Philadelphia escaped the division cellar since 1970.
Schmidt was an MVP in the making for a team on the rise, and he landed his first All-Star nod and a 6th-place finish in the NL’s MVP voting.
-
1974 Topps #105 Carlton Fisk
PSA 9 Value: $850
Total PSA Population: 1,278
PSA 9 Population: 77
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 6.0% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #80 Tom Seaver
PSA 9 Value: $550
Total PSA Population: 2,430
PSA 9 Population: 211
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 8.7% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
The 1974 MLB season saw Tom Seaver post an ERA over 3.00 for the first time in his career while giving up more hits per nine innings than any other season since his rookie year.
Used to eclipsing the 200 strikeout mark with ease, Tom Terrific barely crossed the mark with 201 but still managed to lead the league in strikeouts per nine innings for the fifth year in a row with a 7.7 clip.
Seaver’s drop-off was primarily related to nagging injuries and, at one point, was diagnosed with a sciatic nerve issue and a dislocated pelvis.
That certainly didn’t make things easy on Seaver.
The season was a struggle, to say the least, as the fireballer managed just an 11-11 record, but much of that was due to an unimpressive Mets offense that didn’t give him much run support.
After winning the National League the year before, the Mets fell to a disappointing 71-91 record to finish fifth in the NL East.
-
1974 Topps #575 Steve Garvey
PSA 9 Value: $550
Total PSA Population: 1,035
PSA 9 Population: 83
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 8.0% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
In 1972, L.A. Dodgers third baseman Steve Garvey committed an MLB-worst 28 errors, and rumors swirled that the 23-year-old wouldn’t be with the organization for much longer.
Fast forward two years to 1974, and Garvey completed an improbable jump from potential cut to National League MVP.
At 25 years of age, Garvey was the all-around engine for the N.L. West champion Dodgers.
In 685 plate appearances (642 at-bats), he slashed .312/.342/.469 with 21 home runs and 111 RBI.
He posted his first of six 200-hit seasons and committed just eight errors to earn his first of four consecutive Gold Gloves.
Garvey’s breakthrough season landed him the MVP award by a hair over St. Louis Cardinals legend Lou Brock.
It was quite the full-circle moment for a player who almost lost his job because of poor defense.
And in the postseason, Garvey continued to elevate his game, going a combined 15-for-39 (.385) against Pittsburgh and Oakland, hitting two home runs and driving in six, but the Dodgers fell short of a title.
Yet, within a half-decade, Garvey would lead the franchise to championship glory for the first time in sixteen years.
-
1974 Topps #440 Jim Kaat
PSA 9 Value: $500
Total PSA Population: 254
PSA 9 Population: 32
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 12.6% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #215 Al Kaline
PSA 9 Value: $475
Total PSA Population: 1,496
PSA 9 Population: 91
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 6.1% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #260 Ted Simmons
PSA 9 Value: $450
Total PSA Population: 433
PSA 9 Population: 42
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 9.7% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #2 Hank Aaron Special
PSA 9 Value: $300
Total PSA Population: 1,093
PSA 9 Population: 82
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 7.5% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #2 Hank Aaron Special
PSA 9 Value: $300
Total PSA Population: 1,093
PSA 9 Population: 82
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 7.5% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #350 Bob Gibson
PSA 9 Value: $300
Total PSA Population: 1,967
PSA 9 Population: 223
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 11.3% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #7 Catfish Hunter
PSA 9 Value: $275
Total PSA Population: 628
PSA 9 Population: 62
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 9.9% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #250 Willie McCovey Washington Senators
PSA 9 Value: $250
Total PSA Population: 1,217
PSA 9 Population: 60
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 4.9% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #50 Rod Carew
PSA 9 Value: $250
Total PSA Population: 1,642
PSA 9 Population: 172
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 10.5% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #207 Strikeout Leaders
PSA 9 Value: $250
Total PSA Population: 1,939
PSA 9 Population: 101
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 5.2% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #40 Jim Palmer
PSA 9 Value: $250
Total PSA Population: 1,439
PSA 9 Population: 116
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 8.1% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #280 Carl Yastrzemski
PSA 9 Value: $225
Total PSA Population: 2,392
PSA 9 Population: 235
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 9.8% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #160 Brooks Robinson
PSA 9 Value: $225
Total PSA Population: 1,729
PSA 9 Population: 138
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 8.0% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #340 Thurman Munson
PSA 9 Value: $195
Total PSA Population: 2,624
PSA 9 Population: 254
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 9.7% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
-
1974 Topps #55 Frank Robinson
PSA 9 Value: $185
Total PSA Population: 1,575
PSA 9 Population: 175
PSA 9 Grade Rate: 11.1% (Set Avg.: 39.5%)
1974 Topps Baseball Cards In Review
As you can see, there are plenty of great stars and Hall of Famers within the 1974 Topps set to keep you busy.
The Dave Winfield and Dave Parker rookie cards are also a couple of great options for guys making their cardboard debut.
Ken Griffey Sr. also has his rookie card in this set but its value didn’t quite give it enough boost to make this list.
Within it, there were also several different subsets, including:
- Hank Aaron Tribute (#1 – 6)
- League Leaders (#201 – 208)
- All-Stars (#331 – 339)
- Playoff Highlights (#470 and #471)
- World Series Highlights (#472 – 479)
- Rookie Stars (#596 – 608)
Overall, this is a decent set from a decade that packs plenty of quirks and hobby history within its checklist.
For those collectors on the lookout for great stars and Hall of Famers of the era or just a large checklist to complete, this set has it all.
