Cy Young Baseball Cards: The Ultimate Collector’s Guide

Most Valuable Cy Young Baseball Cards

When it comes to the pre-War segment of the hobby, Cy Young baseball cards will always be among the most desirable.

He is a baseball icon and set the standard for pitchers...

After all, you have to be pretty good to have an award named after you that's given out to the best pitchers year after year.

So, there should be no surprise that Cy Young cards are consistently atop the list of key cards of all the major pre-War sets.

And some of his cards are even among the most valuable baseball cards of any era.

So, in honor of the legendary pitcher, I've developed this list of the most important Cy Young cards you can collect.

Let's jump right in...

More...

Ross Uitts

Ross Uitts - Owner

Are you selling sports cards that were produced from 1868 - 1975?

If so, then please fill out the form below and I'll be in touch right away. Or, feel free to call/text me at 305-684-6680!

1906 Fan Craze American League

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $1,750

Designed as a deck of playing cards in the style of a baseball game, these cards were issued in 1906 by the Fan Craze Company of Cincinnati. Young is one of thirteen Hall of Famers who appear in this set of 54 cards in total. And because it was released early on in the 1900's, it is one of a very few sets to contain players from both the 19th and 20th centuries. A portrait of Young rests in the center of the card with "Hit by pitcher." written across the top to signify the particular action represented by his card in the game.

1906 Fan Craze (American) Cy Young Baseball Card

1909-11 Colgan's Chips Stars of the Diamond

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $1,150

These 1-7/16" discs were distributed in five-cent Colgan's Mint and Violet Chips gum tins over a three-year period from 1909-1911. The black and white image of Young is surrounded by both his name and the Cleveland team name on either side of his head. He is one of 21 Hall of Famers to appear in this set that is filled with variations ranging from misspellings, team name changes, different portraits and different color schemes. However, Cy Young's disc is one that escaped having different variations and appears only in the form you see below.

1909 Colgan's Chips Stars of the Diamond Cy Young Baseball Card

1909 E90-1 American Caramel (Boston)

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $30,000

Up next on our list is the "Boston" version of Young's 1909 American Caramel card, one of the most iconic pre-War sets in the hobby. This is one of many cards in which you'll see this portrait of Young originally created by well-known photographer Carl Horner. The rich red background provides a nice contrast to help Young stand out in his Boston uniform. These are among his more expensive cards that you'll come across.

1909 E90-1 American Caramel (Boston) Cy Young Baseball Card

1909 E90-1 American Caramel (Cleveland)

Estimated PSA 5 EX Value: $7,000

Prior to the start of the 1909 season, Cy Young was traded from Boston to Cleveland. But, by the time the American Caramel Company could change over their printing sheets to update Young's status as a member of Cleveland, most copies made it into circulation in their "Boston" form shown previously. That said, these versions are scarcer than their Boston counterparts: maybe 20% or so in existence are the Cleveland version. That also makes them more expensive than the Boston versions on a grade-for-grade basis.

1909 E90-1 American Caramel (Cleveland) Cy Young Baseball Card

1909-11 T206 Portrait

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $200,000

When it comes to pre-War cards, the T206 set is hands down the king of them all. And while the Honus Wagner card may be the most iconic and expensive of all the T206's, the Cy Young "portrait" card is also high up on the list of the most desirable. This is one of three cards in the set to feature Young and again we see the iconic portrait pose seen across many other Cy Young cards. I've always loved the green background of this card and feel it really helps to give a classy feel to it. Because they're so tough to find in high grade, mint condition examples of this card will set you back six figures while lower grade versions can be had for less than $1,000.

1909-11 T206 White Border Cy Young (Portrait) baseball card

1909-11 T206 Hand Shows

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $125,000

Next up from the trio of T206 Cy Young's is the "Hand Shows" version where Young is depicted doing what he did best: pitching. The multi-colored background really makes this card pop and many collectors consider this to be his best-looking T206 card. It's not quite as valuable as the "Portrait" version, however. Still, high grade examples of this one can also set you back six figures.

1909-11 T206 White Border Cy Young Bare Hand Shows

1909-11 T206 Glove Shows

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $20,000

The last T206 Cy Young, the "Glove Shows" version, is not nearly as desirable as the other two which is reflected by its lower value. The color scheme is kind of bland compared to his other T206 cards. I do like that he is shown pitching and the image of him looking straightforward at the viewer is something hardly ever seen on his other cards.

1909 T206 Glove Showing Cy Young Baseball Card

1910 E93 Standard Caramel

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $25,000

One of Young's most vibrant cards, his E93 Standard Caramel issue is another one of his most highly-desired candy cards. The set itself is fairly small as it contains only 30 players of the era. Like many sets in which he was featured, Young is one of the top four key players to collect along with Honus Wagner, Ty Cobb and Christy Mathewson. I've always thought it was interesting that Young was depicted batting instead of pitching. Regardless, this iconic card possesses stronger eye appeal than many of his other cards.

1910 E93 Standard Caramel Cy Young Baseball Card

1910 E98 Set of 30

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $5,000

Interestingly, Cy Young is not pictured on this card--it's actually an image of Irv Young, another pitcher who played six seasons during the early 1900's. This is one of those instances where this type of error doesn't drastically affect baseball card values since it was never corrected. Had some of these made it into circulation with Cy Young actually depicted then these with Irv Young shown instead would certainly get a boost in value. You can find these cards with one of three background colors: red, blue, and green.

1910 E98 Set of 30 Cy Young Baseball Card

1910 E105 Mello-Mint

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $22,000

These 1-3/8" by 2-5/8" cards were produced on thin paper stock making them incredibly susceptible to damage. Adding to that, many of these had to be folded vertically in order to fit into the pack of gum. Young is one of eleven Hall of Famers to appear in this set of 50 different players. The front image is the same we saw earlier on the 1909 American Caramel issue but the back makes it instantly distinguishable. 

1910 E105 Mello-Mint Cy Young Baseball Card

1910-12 Sweet Caporal Pins

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $500

Not only did the American Tobacco Company produce trading cards, they also produced these 7/8", sepia-toned pins to commemorate many players of the day. The set is riddled with players who can be found in two different variations: "Large Letter" and "Small Letter" types. Both versions are shown below. The "Small Letter" version shows one image of Cy Young with a "C" on his cap while the "Large Letter" version features a completely different image and lists "Old Cy Young" as his name. The reverse sides of these pins can easily show wear to the paper ad insert inside the disc and due to rusting around the borders.

1910 Sweet Caporal Pins 155S Cy Young Baseball Card
1910 Sweet Caporal Pins 155L Cy Young Baseball Card
Reverse Side of a 1910 Sweet Caporal Pin That Shows the Paper Advertisement

1911 E94 George Close Candy

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $25,000

One of the most popular caramel cards, the E94 issue features the legendary Cy Young in a pitching pose set against a any one of seven different background color variations of the set. Two oddities stand out on this card. First, he is identified as “Old” Cy Young along the bottom border of the card. Second, the image of Young used on this card pictures him in a Boston Red Sox uniform even though he is identified with Cleveland on the card. These cards were produced by the George Close Co. of Cambridge, Massachusetts.

1911 George Close Candy Cy Young Baseball Card

1911 M116 Sporting Life

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $6,500

Back again is that familiar portrait of Cy Young although this time it appears in full-color. The pastel-colored background of the card also gives it a more calm and cool feel. The cards in this set were distributed to subscribers of "Sporting Life" magazine in 12-card lots across 24 different series. Cy Young's card can be found with its back printed in either blue or black ink.

1911 Sporting Life Cy Young Baseball Card

1911 T3 Turkey Red Cabinets

Estimated PSA 6 EX-MT Value: $13,500

The 1911 T3 Turkey Red Cabinets cards are considered by many collectors to be among the most beautiful baseball cards ever produced. And I'd have to agree. Measuring in at 5-3/4" by 8", they were much larger than other cards of the era. Customers who bought cigarettes from one of three companies, Turkey Red, Old Mill or Fez, could send in coupons in exchange for the cards. This is arguably the best-looking Cy Young card you can find.

1911 T3 Turkey Red Cabinets Cy Young Baseball Card

1911 T205 Gold Border

Estimated PSA 8 NM-MT Value: $24,000 

The T205 set is one of the most iconic pre-War issues and featured player images inside gold borders that can be susceptible to showing wear quite easily. Many players, like Young, were also depicted atop a baseball diamond backdrop with tools of the sport scattered along the bottom as well. High grade examples can be tough to locate and will easily cost into the five figure range to acquire.

1911 T205 Gold Border Cy Young Baseball Card

Cy Young Baseball Cards Wrap-Up

Cy Young baseball cards are at the top of most every pre-War card collector's want lists and for that reason their values will continue to remain strong for quite some time.

Young's achievements as a pitcher are jaw-dropping.

He won 30 or more games five different times.

He won 2 games in the first World Series which helped lead Boston to victory.

He led the league in wins, strikeouts and ERA in 1901 which would earn him a pitching Triple Crown.

And he even threw the game's first perfect game.

But, some of his achievements which will likely never be surpassed are:

  • 511 Wins
  • 315 Losses
  • 815 Games Started
  • 749 Complete Games
  • 7,356 Inning Pitched
  • 29,565 Batters Faced

The way the game is played, and more importantly the way pitchers are used, has changed drastically since his time.

But his list of stunning achievements are exactly why the best pitcher from each league is awarded the "Cy Young Award" each year in his honor.

There's no question that Young's place in the hobby is held in high regard and collectors will go to great lengths and pay extraordinary prices to chase down his cards.

Ross Uitts
 

Ross is the founder of Old Sports Cards and has been collecting sports cards for over 30 years. He also loves to write about the hobby and has written for Beckett, Topps, SABR and of course, this website. Need help buying or selling cards or have a general question about the hobby? Contact him at [email protected]

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments