15 Most Valuable 1991 Upper Deck Football Cards

A collage of the most valuable cards from the 1991 Upper Deck Football sports card set.A collage of the most valuable cards from the 1991 Upper Deck Football sports card set.

After lighting the baseball card world on fire by entering the hobby in 1989, the 1991 Upper Deck football card set marked the company’s official entrance into the football card world.

And collectors were not disappointed…

Upper Deck brought just as much of the high-quality and premium photography that collectors had grown to love from the young company.

Hobbyists were thrilled at seeing some of their favorite players like Jerry Rice, Barry Sanders, Joe Montana, Dan Marino and many more on premium card stock with sharp imagery.

Though the set debuted during an era of mass production, you might be surprised that some can still be worth something these days.

And in this guide, we’ll take a look at the 15 most valuable in the checklist.

Let’s jump right in!

    1991 Upper Deck Football Cards In Review

    1991 Upper Deck Football Set Snapshot

    Total Cards in Set: 700
    Key Rookie Cards:
    Key Veterans:

    Previous Set:

    Next Set:

    Related Sets:

    ,

    ,

    1991 Upper Deck Grading Analysis

    Total PSA Population: 24,535
    PSA 10 Population: 8,887
    PSA 10 Grade Rate: 36.2%
    Most Graded Card: #13 Brett Favre (10,506)
    2nd Most Graded Card: #647 Brett Favre (4,461)
    3rd Most Graded Card: #54 Joe Montana (803)

    The 1991 Upper Deck football card set clocked in at 700 cards issued across two series.

    Though it does contain several stars and Hall of Famers, the key to the set are the #13 Brett Favre “Star Rookie” and the #647 Brett Favre “Rookie Force” cards.

    Beyond that, big names like Joe Montana, Jerry Rice, Emmitt Smith, Bo Jackson, Barry Sanders and others help round out a set that was pretty flashy for its time.

    Unopened Box of 1991 Upper Deck Football Cards

    There were also several interesting subsets, including:

    • Star Rookies (#1 – 29)
    • Aerial Threats (#30 – 35)
    • Season Leaders (#401 – 406)
    • Team MVP’s (#450 – 487)
    • Rookie Force (#601 – 652)
    • Arch Rivals (#653 – 658)

    The importance of this set lies primarily with the fact that Upper Deck had finally tossed its name into the football card world to try and compete with the other traditional names.

    And they upped the game when it came to quality.

    For those who grew up collecting these cards, I’m sure you can appreciate them still to this day even if their values may not be through the roof.