15 Most Valuable 1976 Topps Baseball Cards

Most Valuable 1976 Topps Baseball Cards

Of all the Topps sets of the 1970s, you may not often hear from collectors that the 1976 Topps baseball card set is their favorite of the decade.

But, that doesn't mean it's a bad set by any means...

It's just that some of the other Topps set designs of the 1970s appeal to more collectors because of how unique they were.

And, the 1976 set doesn't pack any blockbuster rookie cards outside of the Dennis Eckersley rookie.

Still, there is plenty to enjoy about this set from its straightforward design, great imagery of the players, and a fantastic lineup of stars and Hall of Famers.

And in this guide, I'll run through the 15 most valuable to look for.

Let's jump right in!

More...

Ross Uitts

Ross Uitts - Owner

Are you selling sports cards that were produced from 1868 - 1975?

If so, then please fill out the form below and I'll be in touch right away. Or, feel free to call/text me at 305-684-6680!

1976 Topps #19 George Brett

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $5,000

George Brett wasted no time making his mark early in the 1976 MLB season.

From May 8th through the 13th, Brett collected at least three hits in six consecutive contests, tying a Major League Baseball record.

A gap hitter with a patient eye and quick-twitch instincts, Brett looked like a veteran superstar at the tender age of 23.

And as Brett ascended to prominence on the national stage, so did the Royals.

After finishing runner-up in the American League West the year before, seven games behind the Oakland Athletics, K.C. got over the hump in 1976.

And they did it in the sweetest of fashions, holding off a late-season surge by the former Kansas City tenants to bring home the franchise's first division title in its eight-year history.

They also did it with the teammates Hal McRae and Brett battling it out for the league's batting title.

Brett won the crown thanks to a controversial inside-the-park home run in Game 162, finishing with a .333 average to McRae's .332.

After a classic five-game American League Championship Series showdown with the New York Yankees, the Royals were ultimately bounced in their playoff debut.

Brett was electric in his first postseason, hitting .444 and slugging an insane .778 to pace the K.C. offense.

1976 Topps #19 George Brett Baseball Card

1976 Topps #98 Dennis Eckersley Rookie Card

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $2,250

Named the American League's Rookie Pitcher of the Year by the Sporting News the year before, Cleveland Indians ace-in-waiting Dennis Eckersley came into the 1976 MLB season with sky-high expectations.

Yes, the franchise itself was only knee-deep in what would ultimately become a 41-year playoff drought.

But, Eckersley's mere presence on the bump was a reason for optimism for Cleveland's beleaguered faithful.

He rewarded that optimism with a quality sophomore season in 1976, reaching the 200-strikeout mark for the first and only time in his Hall-of-Fame career.

His ERA took a step back from his breakthrough rookie campaign, but his confidence in his devastating fastball/sinker combination seemed to grow from start to start.

Eckersley suffered through a lack of run support in many of his starts in 1976, finishing just a game over .500 despite completing nine of his 30 starts.

Yet while the youthful Indians offense struggled to cash in with runners in scoring position, Eckersley dazzled for long stretches to tease what was possible if the franchise could ever put the pieces fully together.

1976 Topps #98 Dennis Eckersley Rookie Card

1976 Topps #240 Pete Rose

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $2,000

In 1976, the Cincinnati Reds defended their 1975 World Series title with arguably the most impressive return engagement in baseball history to kick the Big Red Machine into full gear.

Cincinnati ran away with the NL West to finish ten games ahead of the second-place Los Angeles Dodgers.

In the postseason, the Reds swept through the Philadelphia Phillies and New York Yankees to complete what is still the only undefeated playoff run of the divisional era.

And it was spearheaded by one of the greatest hitters of his or any era, 35-year-old star third baseman Pete Rose.

Finishing fourth on the National League’s Most Valuable Player ballot, you can make a convincing case that Rose was robbed of at least a top-three placement.

For the second-straight year, Rose led the Majors in runs scored and doubles.

He also led baseball in plate appearances and tied George Brett atop the hits leaderboard with a whopping 215 on the season.

Rose publicly confronted the Cincinnati front office to request a massive pay raise during the offseason.

With public opinion on his side, Rose eventually scored a two-year deal for $752,000 total, over $300,000 more than the Reds had initially offered for the same contract length.

1976 Topps #240 Pete Rose Baseball Card

1976 Topps #550 Hank Aaron

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $1,500

Finishing his legendary career in the city where it started, Milwaukee Brewers designated hitter Hank Aaron had a disappointing statistical season by his lofty standards in 1976.

Aaron appeared in just 85 games for the 66-96 Brewers, hitting a career-low ten home runs in 271 at-bats.

Yet, each of those blasts was an event, including the final one, a crushed hanging slider by California Angels reliever Dick Drago on July 20th, which brought the Aaron career home run counter to 755.

That remained the all-time career home run record for 28 years until Barry Bonds eclipsed the mark in 2004.

Aaron, a natural run-producer with a clutch gene, also ended his 23-year career as the game's all-time RBI leader with 2,297, a mark that may never be eclipsed.

It's fitting, then, that his last MLB at-bat ended with an RBI.

Batting fourth for the Brewers in his final game on October 3rd, 1976, Aaron legged out a sixth-inning RBI infield single off of Detroit Tigers starter Dave Roberts.

Milwaukee manager Alex Grammas removed Aaron for a pinch-runner, sensing history at hand.

After rewriting baseball's record books in his 3,298 games as a player, he retired shortly after that. 

1976 Topps #550 Hank Aaron Baseball Card

1976 Topps #330 Nolan Ryan

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $1,000

Throughout the 1975 MLB season, Nolan Ryan pitched through a pulled calf muscle, a groin injury, two different hamstring pulls, a throwing shoulder injury, a torn biceps tendon in the same arm, and bone chips which ended his season early in the first week of September.

Given a much-needed offseason to rest and recuperate, the native Texan returned to form in 1976.

It just so happened that his form was wildly inconsistent.

The Angels were nothing special in 1976, ambling along to a mediocre 76-86 record and a fourth-place finish in the AL West.

Yet, Ryan's pitching performances were must-see stuff due to their all-or-nothing nature.

After leading Major League Baseball in strikeouts every season from 1972-74, the Ryan Express rolled back to the top of the leaderboard in 1976 with 327.

The bad news was the 183 walks that Ryan issued, making it the fourth time in five years that he paced baseball in free passes.

When he was on point, nobody could hit him.

When he wasn't, the strike zone was the size of a postage stamp.

1976 Topps #330 Nolan Ryan Baseball Card

1976 Topps #302 Rick Miller

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $750

One of the most beloved fan favorites in the long, storied history of the Boston Red Sox, speedy outfielder Rick Miller entered the 1976 MLB campaign with a postseason-sized chip on his shoulder.

The Red Sox cut Miller's playing time dramatically during their march to the 1975 American League pennant, relegating him to fourth on the depth chart behind the dynamic outfield trio of Fred Lynn, Dwight Evans, and Jim Rice.

It was a season-long slight that weighed on Miller.

"It was the absolute worst year I ever had," Miller said. "Fred (Lynn) played all the time, Jim Rice played all the time. If it hadn't been for the World Series, it would have been really bad for me that year, mentally and as a player."

However, come 1976, Miller's role once again increased due to nagging injuries suffered by Lynn.

And e responded with a .283 batting average, his best mark as a member of the Red Sox.

He provided exceptional range and great defense at all three outfield positions and hit just under .300 as a pinch hitter.

Boston took a step back as a team in 1976, falling to 83-79 and third in the AL East.

Yet, Miller stepped forward and reestablished himself as an essential piece of the team's roster puzzle.

1976 Topps #302 Rick Miller Baseball Card

1976 Topps #585 Joe Torre

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $600

Joe Torre's long list of accomplishments as a player is often overlooked in favor of his managerial exploits, but that's honestly a shame.

He was one of the most consistent hitters in the game throughout the 1960s and early 1970s, earning nine All-Star appearances, a Gold Glove, and the 1971 National League MVP award.

Come 1976, Torre's illustrious playing career was nearing its conclusion.

His power numbers had fallen off and he was coming off a 1975 campaign in which he had posted a career-low .247 batting average.

His home run power didn't return during the 1976 season, but his contact-hitting stroke sure did.

Torre hit just five home runs in 310 at-bats for an 86-win Mets team but saw his batting average jump to a robust .306, his fifth and final season with a batting average of .300 or better.

Under the managerial guidance of Joe Frazier, New York appeared to have a plan in place for a return to October glory.

However, that wasn't to be, as he'd last just 45 games into a dismal 1977 season before he was canned.

His replacement? Joe Torre.

1976 Topps #585 Joe Torre Baseball Card

1976 Topps #35 Tony Oliva

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $550

Undoubtedly one of the greatest Major League Baseball players to immigrate from Cuba, Tony Oliva’s career was at an injury-plagued crossroads heading into the 1976 MLB season.

Following the Minnesota Twins’ 1975 campaign, Oliva underwent two different knee surgeries to remove bone spurs, making them his sixth and seventh knee operations.

His career had already been extended once by the institution of the Designated Hitter in the American League in 1973.

But by 1976, his knee issues were proving too much for him to even slot into that role daily.

Heading into Spring Training, Oliva was well aware that his days as an everyday player were probably over.

General manager Calvin Griffith offered him a coaching role under new manager Gene Mauch; however, Oliva wasn’t ready to stop playing.

The two parties came to a compromise, and Oliva transitioned into a player/coach role, working with the team as a first-base coach and hitting instructor.

He started just 32 games and was brought in mainly as a situational pinch hitter and was regularly replaced by a pinch-runner when he got on base.

It wasn’t the most productive swan song on the field, but Oliva’s tutelage and team-oriented mindset helped the Twins finish with a very respectable 86-76 record.

1976 Topps #35 Tony Oliva Baseball Card

1976 Topps #340 Jim Rice

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $550

Fresh off a 1975 debut campaign in which he finished second in the AL Rookie of the Year race and third in the MVP vote, Jim Rice looked to keep up the hot start to his Hall of Fame career in 1976.

His production and efficiency at the plate declined in his sophomore campaign while he led the AL in strikeouts (123), but Rice still turned in a solid year with 25 home runs, 85 RBI, and 75 runs scored.

It was clear that he would be a superstar for years to come.

However, the Red Sox still had work to do to get to the playoffs, as their 83-79 record was good enough for third place in the AL East but still 15.5 games behind the first-place New York Yankees.

Rice kept on chugging, and by 1978, he would be crowned AL MVP.

For all sixteen years of his storied career, Jim Rice gave his all for the Boston Red Sox and retired as one of the biggest legends in franchise history with eight All-Star appearances, two Silver Sluggers, and one MVP to his name.

Unfortunately, Rice and the Red Sox rarely appeared in the playoffs during those sixteen seasons, making it into the post-season only twice in 1986 when they lost to the Mets in the World Series and 1988 when they lost to the A's in the ALCS.

1976 Topps #340 Jim Rice Baseball Card

1976 Topps #300 Johnny Bench

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $500

The 1976 MLB season was both a relief and a pain for future Hall-of-Fame catcher Johnny Bench.

After spending years as one of baseball's most eligible bachelors, Bench married former Miss South Carolina and Miss USA runner-up Vicki Lynne Chesser before the 1975 campaign.

Their tumultuous relationship was tabloid fodder, especially considering they had known each other for just four days before Bench proposed and married at the seven-week mark.

As the Reds unseated the Oakland A's at the top of the baseball mountain, Bench also dealt with a very bright public spotlight on what ended up as a doomed marriage.

The two divorced shortly after the season.

When 1976 rolled around, Bench was able to focus on and fully appreciate the team's ride to back-to-back World Series titles.

However, throughout the 1976 season, Bench played through severe cramps in his back.

Both his defensive play behind the plate and his swing were affected as he hit just .234 and played in 135 regular-season games for the Reds, both career lows.

The postseason, however, was a very different story as Bench sizzled, and the team went 7-for-7 in October, hitting .444 with three home runs in Cincinnati's sweeps of the Phillies and Yankees.

He was named World Series MVP for his efforts, later stating that the second trophy was a "personal triumph" even sweeter than the first.

1976 Topps #300 Johnny Bench Baseball Card

1976 Topps #500 Reggie Jackson

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $500

Considered a lost season of sorts in his Hall-of-Fame career, superstar right fielder Reggie Jackson's one-year stint with the Baltimore Orioles in 1976 was a controversial case of a square peg in a round hole.

With the death of the reserve clause and the opening salvos of free agency, Oakland Athletics owner Charlie Finley traded Jackson (and star pitcher Ken Holtzman) seven days before Opening Day.

Despite repeatedly asking Finley to trade him in the years leading up to this, Jackson was devastated by the deal.

Jackson held out for the first few weeks of the season, declining multiple contract offers from the Baltimore front office before agreeing to a deal.

When he finally put on an Orioles uniform, he was out of shape and visibly uninspired.

This didn't win over Baltimore's fan base, nor did it sit well in the Orioles clubhouse.

It also didn't help that Jackson sputtered until mid-June, hitting barely above .200 with just four home runs to his credit.

As the great ones sometimes can and do, though, Jackson flipped the switch from then on.

Thanks to a three-month tear at the dish, he led the American League in slugging percentage and OPS+, picking up enough MVP votes for a 16th-place finish.

It was a breathtaking about-face, but it wasn't enough to push Baltimore past the Yankees for an AL East title.

1976 Topps #500 Reggie Jackson Baseball Card

1976 Topps #480 Mike Schmidt

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $450

On the shortlist of the best all-around third basemen in baseball history, Philadelphia Phillies legend Mike Schmidt had a banner year in 1976.

And it started with an absolute bang.

While Schmidt’s star had been on the rise since his first All-Star appearance in 1974, his early-season theatrics during the 1976 campaign launched his career into the stratosphere.

Schmidt was molten hot out of the gate, hitting 12 home runs in the Phillies’ first fifteen games.

Four of those dingers came in four consecutive at-bats during an April 17th road game in Chicago.

His heroics that day lit a fire under his Phillies teammates as the team won 55 of its next 77 games leading up to the All-Star break.

And in large part, thanks to Schmidt’s MLB-best 38 home runs and Gold Glove defense at third, they finished the year with 101 wins, nine games clear of the Pittsburgh Phillies as the NL East champs.

Philadelphia’s reward for its regular-season triumph was the unenviable task of derailing the Big Red Machine in the National League Championship Series.

It didn’t happen.

Schmidt hit .308 with two doubles and two RBI in the brief series, but Cincy still steamrolled through Philadelphia for a convincing three-game sweep. 

1976 Topps #480 Mike Schmidt Baseball Card

1976 Topps #1 Hank Aaron Record Breaker

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $400

Hank Aaron had already accomplished the unthinkable on April 8, 1974, when he hit the 715th home run of his career to move past Babe Ruth into the all-time lead.

The following season, he moved past Babe Ruth to set the record for RBI when he drove in the 2,210th run of his career during a game against the Tigers on May 1, 1975.

Aaron kept extending his record the rest of the season before finishing with 2,262.

And, during his final season in 1976, Aaron drove in another 35 runs to finish his career with an eye-popping 2,297 RBI.

His home run record eventually fell to Barry Bonds but his RBI record will likely never be broken.

To commemorate his achievement in 1975, Topps released this card and slotted it in the #1 position in the 1976 set checklist.

1976 Topps #1 Hank Aaron Record Breaker Baseball Card
1976 Topps #1 Hank Aaron Record Breaker Baseball Card Reverse Side

1976 Topps #290 Ted Simmons

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $400

Over a career spanning 21 years with three different teams, switch-hitting Hall of Famer Ted Simmons established himself as one of the greatest hitting catchers in MLB history.

And, since his induction into the Hall of Fame in 2021, his cards have seen a nice uptick in value.

Originally eligible for the Hall of Fame in 1994, Simmons fell off the ballot after receiving less than 5% of the vote but was fortunately later elected in December 2019 via the Veterans Committee.

Simmons hit for .300 or better in seven different seasons, but the 1976 season wasn't one of them.

In fact, his production at the plate was down across the board as he hit just five home runs, scored 60 runs and drove in 75 RBI with an uncharacteristic .291/.371/.394 slash line.

He did lead the league in intentional walks (19) for this first of consecutive seasons, so opposing pitchers still obviously respected him.

Some of his decline in production can be attributed to the Cardinals being lousy in 1976, as they finished 5th in the NL West with a 72-90 record.

1976 Topps #290 Ted Simmons Baseball Card

1976 Topps #599 Ron Guidry Rookie Card

Estimated PSA 9 Mint Value: $400

In 1978, New York Yankees left-hander Ron Guidry was the best pitcher in the Major Leagues.

Just two years before that, though, Guidry was a resident of the infamous George Steinbrenner doghouse.

After providing of glimpse of things to come in ten mostly serviceable outings in 1975, the young Louisiana native looked primed for a big rookie campaign in 1976.

However, the hiring of Billy Martin as Yankees manager put a halt to his professional momentum.

Martin was notoriously not a fan of rookie players and he rarely spoke to the lefty during Spring Training before shipping him down to Triple-A Syracuse ahead of Opening Day.

Guidry was exceptional in his return to the Minors, posting a 1.37 ERA and striking out 25 batters in 20 innings.

After coming to terms on the release of recent trade acquisition Ken Brett in mid-May, the Yankees recalled Guidry to work out of the team's bullpen.

But Martin was just not a fan of the rookie pitcher and left him on the bullpen bench for 47 consecutive games before being demoted back to Syracuse on July 6th.

He returned in August, appearing in just six games before the season's end for the AL East champs.

Guidry did receive a roster spot for the team's ALCS showdown with the Kansas City Royals, but he was only used once in Game 4 and as a pinch-runner nonetheless.

1976 Topps #599 Ron Guidry Rookie Card

1976 Topps Baseball Cards In Review

Though it may seem like this set is sometimes overlooked, there is still plenty to enjoy within the 660-card checklist.

The Dennis Eckersley card is the key rookie in the set by a mile, but there are plenty of great stars and Hall of Famers to boost the overall appeal of the checklist.

The design is simple and straightforward, especially compared to some of the Topps sets from 1970 to 1975 that were a lot more boisterous.

Unopened Pack of 1976 Topps Baseball Cards

Within the set were also several different subsets, including:

  • Milestones (#1 - 6)
  • Father and Son (#66 - 70)
  • League Leaders (#191 - 205)
  • Playoff and World Series Highlights (#461 - 462)

While the hobby may not hold this set in as high of a regard as others from the vintage era, I still think it packs a good punch.

And, if you're lucky to land any of them in high grade, you've obviously got a lot of value on your hands.

Ross Uitts
 

Ross is the founder of Old Sports Cards and has been collecting sports cards for over 30 years. He also loves to write about the hobby and has written for Beckett, Topps, SABR and of course, this website. Need help buying or selling cards or have a general question about the hobby? Contact him at [email protected]

Click Here to Leave a Comment Below 0 comments